Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
96 of 111 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Splendidly Conceived, 19 May 2007
This is the most wonderful television story of the ancient histories yet. Here are the reasons:
1) Unlike many prior feature films and TV series, this does not take Julius Caesar's power as given. Pharsalus, the battle which guaranteed his power, is not a footnote but a crucial historical moment which is given its proper dues here. So are many other details.
2) The deviousness and machinations which were so much a part of Republican-Imperial Rome are left intact. Although it cannot compare with "I Claudius", the series certainly does an excellent job getting close.
3) The sexual scenes and violence are not overdone. Anyone who is aware of the frescoes at Pompeii will know that sex and sexuality were important features of Roman culture. If it strikes you as a "soft porn extravaganza" (Philip Shepherd's comment) then remember that Rome was, at many times, a hard porn extravaganza. See the Penthouse film 'Caligula' and the novels of Mary Renault for other attempts at making us come out of our Victorian shell - long overdue in my opinion.
4) The acting is superb. Absolutely first class. See it for yourself.
5) Much research has clearly gone into the finer details. Notice that the ancient hairstyles are copied. The clothing also appears authentic (no off-the-rack yuppie ripoffs here). Ancient military, surgical, and cosmetic products have also been replicated well.
6) The film corrects many of our misconceptions. Though we may recall, with fondness, the fine nobility of Shakespeare's 'Antony and Cleopatra' this film provides a much-needed revision of these characters' identities. Antony is a thuggish brute and Cleopatra a coquettish nymphomaniac. There is nothing surprising here except the breathtaking audacity in making it plain. Wow!
7) The series does not fall into the trap of making the stories a purely upper-class affair. Much of it must be, if only because the ancient histories adopt the same approach. Yet a lot of the action takes place at the level of the common people. This too is quite revolutionary for a drama of this type.
8) Quite a few different scriptwriters and directors have been involved. They seem to change from episode to episode. The strength of this series clearly results from this inclusive, all-embracing approach.
If there are weaknesses, they lie in the slightly restrictive depiction of Rome as a city. At its height, Rome was a giant metropolis. This series makes it feel more like a provincial city than an imperial capital. That said, there's not much else to complain about and a huge amount to enjoy. High praise! Applause! Accolades! Bona Dea, please let the series continue right through the Julio-Claudian era - and beyond!
|
|
|
86 of 101 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Emphasises character and story over spectacle, 2 Aug 2006
"Rome" is a well-executed fictional rendition of the latter period of Julius Caesar's life, from around 52BC with the surrender of Vercingetorix ("King of all the Gauls"), up to the newly proclaimed dictator's assassination at the hands of his fellow senators in 44BC. The series takes certain historical liberties. I didn't mind them in the least, but if that sort of thing bothers you...then it will bother you.
In any case, there's much more here than a history lesson or a biography of Caesar. There are multiple, interwoven storylines, based on tensions between different (groups of) characters, and it's not just the military men who drive the action: the conflict between Attia of the Julii (Caesar's niece) and Servilia of the Brutii (Brutus's mother) is like subtle, bitter warfare and drives much of the rest of the plot.
Another central strand involves the comradeship and sometime friendship between two lowly soldiers, Lucius Voranus and Titus Pullo. These two characters and their adventures (both military and domestic) provide some relief from the doings of all the senators and Patricians. Voranus and Pullo bring a human (and often comic) scale to the proceedings.
The writing/storytelling is superb. Time after time, I enjoyed a particular line--often I was waiting for it, having remembered it from the BBC presentation. The acting is (mostly) hard to fault, as is the evocation of ancient Rome through the sets, costumes and rituals. One thing I will mention is that I preferred the pace of the BBC's opening episodes, which were apparently cut down from three episodes, much to director Michael Apted's dismay. The original cut (which is what's on these DVDs) has more political exposition. The BBC cut was faster-paced. I didn't know about this when I watched the DVDs, and I was puzzled as to why it didn't seem quite as compelling as the BBC broadcasts. It goes to show that more isn't always better (but maybe if you know nothing of the period, the extra background will be helpful).
Another weakness for some will be the lack of military spectacle: the story includes major battles such as Pharsalus and Thapsus, but all we really see are the aftermaths (exhausted generals, dead soldiers, dying elephants). Then again, would you prefer to hear Pompey explaining how he lost at Pharsalus, where the odds seemed overwhelmingly in his favour, or to try to glimpse events by watching thousands of choreographed, costumed extras? With "Rome", you get the former. If you want the latter, try the opening battle from the film "Gladiator".
Which brings me to one of the most memorable scenes: a small-scale but deadly gladiatorial contest involving two of the main characters. Some of the limb-chopping seems a bit over the top, but there's a sense of squalor as well as of heroism, completely unlike the arena scenes in Gladiator (which to be fair would have dated from much later, when the gladiatorial arts had been more fully developed).
What's fully developed in Rome is the characters: there isn't a single one that isn't deeply flawed, and therefore human. One of the reasons why that simple gladiator scene works so well is that you can engage with the characters as people, not just as heroic ciphers.
The documentary-style extras aren't much to write home about: I could take them or leave them. There are also episode commentaries, for those who really want to delve into the production.
Finally, the DVDs come in the best packaging ever. Cardboard was evidently not considered good enough for this series: it comes in a sturdy board box with bevelled edges, and is so seamless it took me a few moments to work out how it opened. There's even artwork hidden under the DVD trays, where you would expect to see nothing more than a piece of white card.
The great thing is, they paid just as much attention to the details of the production, as to the box.
|
|
|
36 of 43 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A glimmer of brilliance in an otherwise mediocre age of telly., 26 Mar 2007
Rome is one of the best pieces of television you are likely to see for the next few years. It's got everything people have come to expect from an HBO drama, fantastic acting and characterisation, lavish and authentic set pieces and addictively compelling story arcs. I noticed some reviews here complain about Rome having too much violence, sex and also that it is historically inaccurate. Well, in my humble opinion all the violence and sex is there for a reason, remember that these were pretty harsh times and these vices were part of everyday life. As for it being historically inaccurate, it's a TV drama! Not a documentary! Of course the cast and crew are going to use artistic lisence! It's such a shame that Rome has went the way of the fantastic Carnivale (another HBO drama) in that it's been cancelled after the second season. It almost reduces me to tears that gems like these are cancelled while other, considerably far worse, programmes run for 10 seasons and produce countless rubbish spin-offs which also go on for years. WHEN WILL PEOPLE LEARN!? Buy this right now, at the price you really cant go wrong. Be quick to watch it though,as series 2 is going to be shown here in April (apparantly) and you'll need to be up to speed to fully appreciate it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![Rome: The Complete HBO Season 1 (6 Disc Box Set) [DVD] [2005]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51TPAJS3NBL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Rome: Complete HBO Seasons 1 And 2 [DVD] [2005]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/510xw2Om7bL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Rome - The Complete Second Season [2006] [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/61xSTb9EGHL._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![The Tudors: Complete Series 1 [DVD] [2007]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/512CVyiZK5L._SL75_SS50_.jpg)
![Rome - The Complete Second Season [2006] [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/61xSTb9EGHL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Kevin McKidd
![The Tudors: Complete Series 1 [DVD] [2007]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/512CVyiZK5L._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Jonathan Rhys Meyers
![The Tudors: Complete Series 2 [DVD] [2008]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51nyKtP1w2L._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Jonathan Rhys Meyers
![City of Vice - Series 1 [2007] [DVD] [2008]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/516W%2BOQ5lfL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Ian McDiarmid
![Deadwood: Complete HBO Season 1 [2004] [DVD]](http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51ZS65WJFCL._SL500_SS90_.jpg)
DVD ~ Ian McShane
