Most people know the Waterboys for the seminal "The Whole of the Moon", a song which still brings nostalgic tears to the eyes of many an ageing ex-80s indie kid. In fact they were one of the most eclectic, versatile bands of the 80s, with a repertoire starting in dark, New Romantic-tinged keyboard pop and ranging widely through rock, blues, Irish folk-rock and the occasional epic ballad. The new album somehow manages to fuse all these influences, along with Scott's continual obsessions with ancient British mythology and the writings of C.S. Lewis, but the sound is bigger, grander, and (quite simply) more utterly pompous than anything that's gone before. The folky guitars of the last three albums have been superseded by a gargantuan, electric sound, but the trademark Scott whimsy is everywhere. So what exactly is "A Rock in the Weary Land"? Scott himself describes it as an account of his personal journey. There's a dark, cynical side to it (the sheer cacophony of "Dumbing Down the World" and the icy, tragic bitterness of the brilliant "Is She Conscious?" have no comparison on any previous Waterboys album) and a heavy dose of the ironic, the confuse.....This is not an easy album to get into because very few of the pieces stand out as songs in their own right. This album is all about atmosphere, a continual brooding epic of keyboard, choirs and thunderous guitars which seems to owe more to the great Prog Rock bands of the 70s than to the Celtic influences of the middle period Waterboys. Ironic really from the man who once complained about someone "running around banging your drum like it's 1973"! Breaths of fresh air in between the grandeur are few and far between (the gorgeous, simple "It's All Gone" somehow helps make the first few songs a lot less intimidating; there should have been more of this!). As an introduction to the band, this is not the album to recommend (try "This is the Sea" or "Fisherman's Blues" instead), but if you've been hooked before by Mike Scott's capacity for quirky storytelling, you'll probably grow to love this.
As a final word, though, I have to mention "We Are Jonah". Not just the stand-out track (and the one most likely to leave its melody engraved in your mind), this is possibly the most surreal bit of writing Scott has ever produced. It must surely rank alongside Carole King's "Tapestry" and the Beatles' "I Am the Walrus" as one of *the* most psychedelic songs of all time. It's worth getting hold of the album just to hear this one.