SOME called it the British Watergate, although it was hardly in the Nixon league of abuse of position and power. In 1975, on a lonely moor in Devon, a Great Dane called Rinka was shot as she tried to protect her owner, horse trainer Norman Scott, from a gunman hell-bent on killing him, former airline steward Andrew Newton. Why did Newton try to kill Scott? Many suspected it was because of Scott's repeated claim that he'd been seduced by Liberal leader Jeremy Thorpe, who wanted to silence him once and for all. In 1979, Jeremy Thorpe was cleared of conspiracy to murder at the Old Bailey. Yet many felt that the trial was a whitewash, an orchestrated cover-up by the Establishment who wished to protect Thorpe. Now, years later and with Thorpe's eagerly-awaited memoirs due to be printed, Simon Freeman has teamed up with the man who broke the story, Barrie Penrose, to re-evaluate the Thorpe affair once and for all. And his conclusions are not the sort of thing Mr. Thorpe's lawyers would approve of. The story begins with Thorpe's childhood and schooldays, going on through his early political career at Oxford, where he backstabbed his way to President of the Union, and then it gets interesting. Thorpe's rise to power is superbly documented, as is that fateful night in 1961 when Thorpe allegedly seduced a young stable-boy called Norman Josiffe. Josiffe, aka Scott, never forgot that supposed encounter no matter how hard Thorpe tried to. The rest of the book follows their parallel lives - Thorpe's culminating in being hours away from a Cabinet post and Scott's with repeated nervous breakdowns. Scott hounded Thorpe over the next decade, telling his story to anyone who would hear. The scandal was about to break when a Great Dane was shot in Devon. Coincidence? So the jury would have us believe. But Freeman and Penrose stick to their guns. Neither of the protagonists in the book are portrayed heroically. Thorpe is depicted as a waspish closet homosexual while Scott comes across as a lonely neurotic more at home with animals than humans. The story of how Penrose and his colleague Roger Courtoir broke the story is also included - reccomended reading for any would-be journalist, as is the BBC's ham-fisted attempt to gag the pair. The trial itself recieves only limited coverage, while the actions of Judge Cantley who practically ordered the jury to acquit Thorpe are contemptuously judged themselves. 'Rinkagate' is a superb read ...
Tony Mullen, Goldsmiths' College, University of London 8.3.99