1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
With so many glaring errors about "Alien"....., 19 July 2008
This review is from: Ridley Scott (Pocket Essentials) (Paperback)
How can I trust anything the writer comes up with?
For example; The terrible synopsis says the astronauts find "A bizarre pod field" - to describe the egg chamber. No mention of the Derelict.
And also it says the company name Weyland-Yutani was a name from polish writer Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness... Yeah right - As much as the Nostromo and the Narcissus were, that certainly wasn't!
For the record it's Weylan-Yutani in Alien, named after a combo of British Leyland and Yutani was a japanese neighbour of Ron Cobb
It makes mention of genius Alexandro Jodorowski's aborted Dune project of the 70s- the art team of which included HR Giger and the rest of the guys hired for Alien - and yet this doesn't get mentioned until the book covers Blade Runner, and never mentions their prior connections. Giger designed the Harkonnen planet by the way.
And also, the author thinks Gladiator is good, and not a second rate big budget rip off from Milius' Conan the Barbarian. Granted - this is subjective and not a concrete fact, but surely someone who claims to have knowledge of film, can see that it's a vapid (though glossy) piece of dunderheaded hollywood slop.
Basically, as I teach Film making, I know the films I like, and I know a LOT about them as it's my job. I bought this book to find out more about Scott's other films - but as I say, with errors this glaringly poor how can I trust anything Brian J Cobb says? Please Brian - email me and tell me I'm wrong!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No