Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Gripping tour of old eastern world, 13 Aug 2002
Bizarre reviews from the people who are down on this book - this is a wonderful read! Brilliant the way Milton has managed to get into places that others haven't, his description of his time at St Catherine's, Sinai, for example, is a revelation, and nobody reading this book could have doubts that Mandeville should be taken much more seriously than in the last hundred years. Milton appears to be able to get into places, and people's lives, in ways that others don't, and whilst this is a series of travellers tales, it very cleverly follows, and casts light on, Mandeville's life and travels. I found it particularly informative (and very moving) when describing the early church and it's numerous splits, schismatics and heresies, and their relationship with Islam; the way Milton sought out, and had conversations with, last survivors of these early times is just wonderful. At it's best, a really breathtaking book.
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Charlatan or Visionary?, 13 April 2002
John Mandeville's writing of 1370 proved pivotal in the flurry of exploration that followed in the wake of 1492. His assertion that the world was a globe (flying in the face of accepted dogma) and that it was possible to travel by sea to the Far East, was THE incentive that drove the expeditions of hundreds of explorers and merchants. Later, the book was ridiculed as hokum, but Giles Milton felt there were enough grains of truth in the manuscript to warrant more research, which he does in his usual comprehensive manner. The result is a very readable unravelling of the mystery, shrouded as it was by the interfering pens of earlier 'editors'. Given the extent of the tinkering, we may never know the truth behind the 'Travels', but Mr milton uncovers enough evidence to show that Mandeville almost certainly DID travel to the Levant, but casts doubt on the veracity of his claims to have travelled to the Far East. The latter is understandably not well-researched, given the ambiguity of the literary data and lack of physical evidence, so only 4 stars. However, in South America 300 years later, Drake describes strange people with almost identical characteristics to Mandeville's 'imaginary' creatures - are we being swayed by modern interpretations of medieval descriptions? We may never know, but this uncertainty and the nuggets of truth unearthed by Mr Milton's research in the Middle-East prompted me to order a copy of the 'Travels', so I could judge for myself whether Mandeville was an early Munchausen or a true visionary. A worthwhile read to stimulate your imagination.
|
|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An interesting and often funny book, 17 Jan 2002
By A Customer
In response to existing reviews, I found this book both interesting and amusing. I have not read John Mandevilles account of his travels, but having read Giles Miltons book, I will certainly look out for it. The book itself contains many interesting and informative sections - I found the one on Jerusalem particularly good, descriptive and thought-provoking. The author involves the reader both in his quest to retrace Sir Johns steps and in his motivation to do so. I was inspired to read this book by Giles Miltons Nathaniel's Nutmeg and Big Chief Elizabeth which I also enjoyed - it did not disappoint ! If you enjoyed these books, try the Riddle and the Knight also. Giles Milton has an easy to read style which interests and entertains.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|