In the immediate aftermath of the sinking of the Titanic, almost a full century ago, both the British and American governments launched formal inquiries into the circumstances of the disaster. A couple of years ago,Titanic expert Samuel Halpern was browsing through the British Wreck Commission report when he began musing how that report would have differed had the investigators had access to the additional information (and improved analytical tools) developed over the past hundred years. So, Halpern recruited an All Star team of Titanic experts to, in essence, create a new "Report into the Loss of the SS Titanic".
The members of this Titanic superteam did more than simply contribute information relative to their own individual specialized areas of research. Instead, they reviewed, debated, and critically analyzed each other's work so that the best, most tested conclusions made it into this new "Centennial Reappraisl" (although of course sometimes this necessitated a "most likely" or "educated guess" solution to a difficult question, with the full knowledge that for some matters we never have any final answers.
This in not a book for a Titanic newbie. To appreciate or even understand the mass of information presented, the reader must bring a substantial previous Titanic knowledge to the table. Although the material is presented in chapters (and appendices) arranged in a fundamentally chronological order, the result is not a smooth, continuous narrative. Rather. the book is more like a collection of highly detailed, often technical, essays on various aspects of the Titanic's story. Centers of bouyancy and angles of heel and ships' bearings and headings do not make for light reading, but for a true Titanic buff, particularly one of the "rivet-counter" persuasion, "A Centennial Reappraisal" is a real treasure chest. I have never read so comprehensive (and comprehensible) discussion of the division of the ship into watertight compartments.
No single previous volume -- or, for that matter, any reasonable collection of previous volumes -- comes close to matching the worth of this book.
The emphasis in "A Centennial Reappraisal" is upon what happened to the ship itself (and the rescue efforts); the chapters upon damage to the ship and the sequence of sinking and upon the activities of the Californian and the Mount Temple are masterpieces of detail and thoughtful analysis. There is, however, little attention paid to the personal experiences of passengers, their accounts being pretty much limited to observations of particular events or in regard to the question of whether locked gates kept Third Class passengers from accessing the lifeboats.
"A Centennial Reappraisal" would not be the very best place to research the human drama in which the passengers (and crew) were caught up in (although there are enough first-hand account excerpts to give some flavor of that), but for any commited Titanic buff who is focused upon the technical details of what occured on that April night in the North Atlantic, than can scarcely be imagined a better book. I have read very many Titanic volumes, and this one has immediately secured a permanent place on my bookshelves, handy for quick reference and thoughtful browsing.