Every scientist - irrepsective of their personal worldview - should read this book.
Careful dissection of atheism and scientism (and their results) are honestly compared with the Theistic framework.
Examination of the history of modern science reveals that science was incubated in a Theistic matrix.
Philosophy of science is very well summarised. Post modernism is rejected in favour of a critical realist foundation - a view reflected by many others (eg McGrath, Polkinghorne etc.). The parallels between some aspects of scientific method and Theism are valid, providing foundations for future work.
I especially enjoyed Chapter 8 - "Reweaving The Rainbow" with its emphasis on the complementarity of scientific and religious knowledge. Areas covered include:
critical realism, cohernce, common sense, objectivity, refutation, committment, scientism, models.
A fully descriptive view of the world is multi-level.
Chapters 9 & 10 deal with the accepted paradigm of evolutionary biology. A mainstream Thesitic view of creation is presented and religious implications examined (Paley, Dawkins, Deism, recent creationsim).
Chapter 11 critiques evolutionary naturalism ie the attempt to construct a worldview on the explanatory powers of evolutionary theory (eg Michael Ruse).
There is a clear call to endorse scientific method : though not be at the expense of abandoning a unified worldview. A Theistic framework provides "a matrix for science in which the validity of scientific knowledge is justified and in which the fruits of scientific discoveries are channelled in ways that affirm human value, justice and care for the environment."
This work was illuminating.
Yes it repeated much of what I have read in history & philosophy of science, cosmology, theology, biology/evolutionary studies - but in a very accessible manner; succinct yet enough depth/clarity for a full understanding of the issues (with refernces to other work to delve deeper).
Minor niggles are lack of an alphabetic bibliography and some diagrams/illustrations.
The price of the book is excellent relative to the amount/depth of its content.
If this is the kind of thoughtful in-depth work produced by members of CIS -I want to read and learn much more....
A must-have for those exploring the interface between science - theology.
Those holding exclusive views (eg Atheists and young earth creationists) would benefit greatly.
Many scientists busy within their specialist area often lack time to read about overarching issues - I would strongly recommend this book to every working scientist.