The original mix of this album was unbalanced, tinny and bloodless, so a full remix was welcome. This version corrects a lot of the faults of the original, and it seems to me they got the mix about right. It rocks.
But the mastering is utterly awful.
Iggy Pop apparently kept saying "Make it louder! Distort the hell out of it!" As a result this is probably the loudest CD ever released; louder than
(What's the Story) Morning Glory?; louder than
Californication; louder than the ludicrous
Death Magnetic. There's no dynamics, no subtlety, no punch, just a continuous, fatiguing wall of gruesome noise. There's so much digital distortion it's physically painful to listen to, and if you forget to turn your volume right down before you listen to it, God help your ears.
You might like the fact that it's an unrestrained monster of ridiculous loudness. If so, fine, that's up to you. Call me old-fashioned, but I like music that actually sounds good. Music where the drums don't vanish when the guitars kick in; where louder parts of songs are, you know, louder, not just more crushed.
Potentially this is the best rock & roll album of all time, which is why it makes me sad that it's been treated so badly. This record needed a proper reworking. But this isn't it.