Being a novice that's had the odd bash on real kits, this drum set hits all the right spots.
It's incredibly well made for starters and looks like a real pro piece of hardware. Yes there are cheaper kits out there and that £500 is still going to be quite an investment in a new hobby but if you're serious about wanting to learn, have an eager sibling ready to start, or have a real drum kit somewhere else and you want to keep quiet at home, you really should look no further than this entry level Roland. It's really refreshing to see and hear an entry level kit that smacks of quality, will live past the basic stages of learning and not fall apart after six months.
I suppose it says something that this is marketed at us beginners and more experienced players. On the latter I wouldn't dare to comment how it stacks up but it's easy to imagine that it's still a decent kit for casual home use. Check out the online demo videos to see how the pros play it and you'll see why.
You're paying for Roland quality, a very good mesh snare drum and a realistic acoustic kit sound. As the bass drum peddle doesn't activate an actual pad it'll keep the noise down still further although it is said you'll lose a little of the feel of a bass peddle. But at least it'll teach your right foot what to do. Cheaper starter kits have this as do premium electro kits but it doesn't seem a great loss when the HD1 design aids its compactness, tiny footprint and feel. There are only a couple of minor niggles that might frustrate ultimate progress are the lack of a choke on the cymbals - you will still instinctively grasp the ringing cymbal if you've played before - and no rim shot. Plus it seems there are no upgrade options but hey let's not forget this is really a starter / practice kit and a year or two down the line, best bet is you'll be adding an acoustic kit anyway.
Roland have a bespoke monitor speaker add on for use without headphones but if you have a low watt practice amp or a stereo or PC speakers they'll do just as well with the right connectors. It's unlikely to match the best way to play which is through headphones where your sound comes alive and doesn't disturb the neighbours. The attached sound module has plenty of normal and funky kit sounds and a metronome. Don't get misled by other kits that have much more; who needs 20 zillion sound samples when you're learning anyway? The Roland's 10 kits will suit you just fine. Don't forget you'll need sticks and a stool which will add another £50 and there are free good tutorials on the web, with no download. This reviewer invested in Tommy Igoe's Groove Essentials DVD,
Tommy Igoe - Groove Essentials [2004] [DVD] which for beginners and improving players is judged well to keep you practising basics and then more advanced beats.
So if you're thinking about it, do not hesitate. There's even a set up and mini tutorial DVD which rounds off what is simply a superb starter drum kit.
Now for lots of counting to four and making the hands and feet behave. Go drum.