Price:£14.99+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

- Quantum Theory (Dover Books on Physics)
- ›
- Customer Reviews

Price:£14.99+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

Your rating(Clear)Rate this item

Share your thoughts with other customers

ByA customeron 18 April 2003

Quantum Theory is never going to be an easy, non-mathematical subject to study. Having said that, the first part of Prof Bohm's work, consisting of some 170 pages, makes a concerted effort to not only explain the experimental basis of quantum theory, but also to explain why it is reasonable compared to classical physics. Whilst all books claim to be able to pull off this feat using "the minimum of mathematics", Prof Bohm does a much better job than most.

The text is actually dated as 1951, this being a Dover reprint. That should not discourage you, however. This material will never be old and out of date since it covers the basics of the subject, as well as more advanced material.

Prof Feynman is renowned for his ability to present Physics in a simple and understandable manner. He achieves this well with his "Lectures on Physics" volumes I and II. However, volume III on Quantum Mechanics falls well short of the mark, and in many respects Bohm's "Quantum Theory" is a much better introduction to the subject. For further contrast one could consider Prof Heitler's "The Quantum Theory of Radiation" which, by comparison with Bohm, seems to use the maximum of mathematics and the minimum of explanation!

Bohm's Quantum Theory can be appreciated at two levels. Firstly, Part I of the book can be read without any particular regard to the mathematics. It is easy enough to read around the equations as if they were not present. There are in fact large tracts where mathematics is shunned in favour of descriptive prose. Now you should understand that this is something that most authors studiously avoid. Quantum Theory is usually presented as being incomprehensible except in terms of mathematics and Prof Bohm proves that this is not necessary.

Secondly, one could dive into the mathematics and discover the remaining two thirds of the book; I for one am content with the "easy" third and consider the book good value for money on the basis of this part alone.

Leslie Green CEng MIEE

The text is actually dated as 1951, this being a Dover reprint. That should not discourage you, however. This material will never be old and out of date since it covers the basics of the subject, as well as more advanced material.

Prof Feynman is renowned for his ability to present Physics in a simple and understandable manner. He achieves this well with his "Lectures on Physics" volumes I and II. However, volume III on Quantum Mechanics falls well short of the mark, and in many respects Bohm's "Quantum Theory" is a much better introduction to the subject. For further contrast one could consider Prof Heitler's "The Quantum Theory of Radiation" which, by comparison with Bohm, seems to use the maximum of mathematics and the minimum of explanation!

Bohm's Quantum Theory can be appreciated at two levels. Firstly, Part I of the book can be read without any particular regard to the mathematics. It is easy enough to read around the equations as if they were not present. There are in fact large tracts where mathematics is shunned in favour of descriptive prose. Now you should understand that this is something that most authors studiously avoid. Quantum Theory is usually presented as being incomprehensible except in terms of mathematics and Prof Bohm proves that this is not necessary.

Secondly, one could dive into the mathematics and discover the remaining two thirds of the book; I for one am content with the "easy" third and consider the book good value for money on the basis of this part alone.

Leslie Green CEng MIEE

Quantum Theory by David Bohm, Prentice-Hall, 1951; Dover, 1989; 672 ff.

A basic quantum theory textbook

Howard Jones

This is a comprehensive `introductory' textbook of quantum mechanics. I put the word `introductory' in quotes because this is not a textbook for the faint-hearted who feel intimidated by mathematics, or for the beginner who is new to the fundamental ideas of the subject. Indeed, to get to the heart of this book the reader needs to be a graduate in mathematics and physics. True, there are great swathes of text explaining in as simple terms as possible the basic concepts of quantum physics, presented in Bohm's usual very readable style. As these are eloquently written by one of the pioneers of the subject, they are well worth reading, even if one ignores the mathematics.

However, as early as page 7 we meet some integral calculus, Maxwell's electromagnetic equations that describe the relationship between electric and magnetic fields, the nabla or del notation that represents a three-dimensional partial derivative operator, and then the notion of divergence describing the variations of a vector field at a given point. Page 10 brings us to Fourier analysis using triple integrals. I don't know what book the other reviewers have read, but these concepts will be meaningless to anyone other than an able graduate in physics and mathematics. They would certainly be incomprehensible even to my A-level maths and physics students.

So, if we exclude the maths, that leaves about one-third of the book as accessible descriptive text which is indeed very well worth reading and informative in its own right, but the significance of which is lost without the mathematics. What this book does, it does brilliantly - but for a very limited and rather specialized readership. For those wanting a historical approach to quantum mechanics there is an excellent book by Manjit Kumar. The basic ideas are explained well by Jim al-Khalili or by Brian Greene, and the practical applications by Alastair Rae. Then there's the Very Short Introduction to Particle Physics by Frank Close. All these books give modern presentations of various aspects of subatomic particle physics and quantum theory that are more accessible for the general non-specialist reader.

Dr Howard A. Jones is the author of The Thoughtful Guide to God (2006) and The Tao of Holism (2008), both published by O Books of Winchester, U.K.; and The World as Spirit published by Fairhill Publishing, Whitland, West Wales, 2011.

Quantum: A Guide for the Perplexed

Quantum: Einstein, Bohr and the Great Debate About the Nature of Reality

The Fabric of the Cosmos: Space, Time and the Texture of Reality (Penguin Press Science)

Particle Physics: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

A basic quantum theory textbook

Howard Jones

This is a comprehensive `introductory' textbook of quantum mechanics. I put the word `introductory' in quotes because this is not a textbook for the faint-hearted who feel intimidated by mathematics, or for the beginner who is new to the fundamental ideas of the subject. Indeed, to get to the heart of this book the reader needs to be a graduate in mathematics and physics. True, there are great swathes of text explaining in as simple terms as possible the basic concepts of quantum physics, presented in Bohm's usual very readable style. As these are eloquently written by one of the pioneers of the subject, they are well worth reading, even if one ignores the mathematics.

However, as early as page 7 we meet some integral calculus, Maxwell's electromagnetic equations that describe the relationship between electric and magnetic fields, the nabla or del notation that represents a three-dimensional partial derivative operator, and then the notion of divergence describing the variations of a vector field at a given point. Page 10 brings us to Fourier analysis using triple integrals. I don't know what book the other reviewers have read, but these concepts will be meaningless to anyone other than an able graduate in physics and mathematics. They would certainly be incomprehensible even to my A-level maths and physics students.

So, if we exclude the maths, that leaves about one-third of the book as accessible descriptive text which is indeed very well worth reading and informative in its own right, but the significance of which is lost without the mathematics. What this book does, it does brilliantly - but for a very limited and rather specialized readership. For those wanting a historical approach to quantum mechanics there is an excellent book by Manjit Kumar. The basic ideas are explained well by Jim al-Khalili or by Brian Greene, and the practical applications by Alastair Rae. Then there's the Very Short Introduction to Particle Physics by Frank Close. All these books give modern presentations of various aspects of subatomic particle physics and quantum theory that are more accessible for the general non-specialist reader.

Dr Howard A. Jones is the author of The Thoughtful Guide to God (2006) and The Tao of Holism (2008), both published by O Books of Winchester, U.K.; and The World as Spirit published by Fairhill Publishing, Whitland, West Wales, 2011.

Quantum: A Guide for the Perplexed

Quantum: Einstein, Bohr and the Great Debate About the Nature of Reality

The Fabric of the Cosmos: Space, Time and the Texture of Reality (Penguin Press Science)

Particle Physics: A Very Short Introduction (Very Short Introductions)

0Comment*|*4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse#### There was a problem loading the comments at the moment. Please try again later.

Please write at least one word

You must purchase at least one item from Amazon to post a comment

A problem occurred while submitting your comment. Please try again later.

Byᅟon 29 April 2009

Maybe the best introduction there is for physicists, but it would not do for a mathematics course. The first part is useful in that it explains a lot of the philosophy behind quantum theory, and the second part is a pretty standard quasi-mathematical treatment of the bare bones of the classical theory, ie, with none of the particle interaction applications.

Unfortunately, the thinking reader will still come away from it wondering what an observer really is, ie, can an observer be another particle or a bit of apparatus? Still, the book does more than most in explaining how phase changes cancel wave interactions and so destroy interference patterns. Most books wave their authors' hands at this point.

It would have been good to have seen more on the relationship between quantum probabilities and Bayesian probabilities in the observation process. Also, the usual treatment of the hydrogen atom with a drawing of the probability clouds of the first few orbitals makes the universal mistake of confusing the arbitrary direction in which the author pointed his z-axis with the physical direction in which one of these clouds has symmetries.

Still the best of a bad bunch after all these years, though.

Unfortunately, the thinking reader will still come away from it wondering what an observer really is, ie, can an observer be another particle or a bit of apparatus? Still, the book does more than most in explaining how phase changes cancel wave interactions and so destroy interference patterns. Most books wave their authors' hands at this point.

It would have been good to have seen more on the relationship between quantum probabilities and Bayesian probabilities in the observation process. Also, the usual treatment of the hydrogen atom with a drawing of the probability clouds of the first few orbitals makes the universal mistake of confusing the arbitrary direction in which the author pointed his z-axis with the physical direction in which one of these clouds has symmetries.

Still the best of a bad bunch after all these years, though.

0Comment*|*4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse#### There was a problem loading the comments at the moment. Please try again later.

Please write at least one word

You must purchase at least one item from Amazon to post a comment

A problem occurred while submitting your comment. Please try again later.

ByMR C BETONon 15 October 2015

All excellent!

0Comment*|*Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse#### There was a problem loading the comments at the moment. Please try again later.

Please write at least one word

You must purchase at least one item from Amazon to post a comment

A problem occurred while submitting your comment. Please try again later.

Let us know here.

Unlimited One-Day Delivery and more

Prime members also enjoy exclusive access to movies and TV shows, a million songs and much more.

There's a problem loading this menu at the moment.

Back to top

Get to Know Us | Make Money with Us | Amazon Payment Methods | Let Us Help You |

- Conditions of Use & Sale
- Privacy Notice
- Cookies & Internet Advertising
- © 1996-2016, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates

|43 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse