Most Helpful Customer Reviews
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Short Big Punch-Up, 21 Aug 2003
This review is from: Punch-Drunk Love [DVD] [2010] (DVD)
After making his 180 minute epic Magnolia, director PT Anderson was asked by the press what his next project would be. He announced he was making a 90 minute comedy starring Adam Sandler, to hearty laughter from the assembled hacks. And then he made Punch-Drunk Love, a 90 minute comedy, starring Adam Sandler. Well, sort of... Sandler plays Barry Egan, a man who is seemingly terrified by the world and also suffering from some kind of obsessive compulsive disorder. The film tracks his persecution at the hands of a chatline operator and his 'chance' meeting with a girl which leads to the Love of the title. But why Punch-Drunk too? Possibly because in the first half of the film Barry is subjected to glaring lights, clanging noises, the hen-pecking of his seven sisters and a physical beating...and then he follows Emily Watson's Lena on a business trip and his whole life changes. Punch-Drunk Love veers between hectic, intense scenes to blissful dreaminess. The cinematography is superb, but likewise swings from steadicam loveliness to handheld paranoia. All the while, the soundtrack reflects this too with jittering, jerky themes melting into sweet hawaiian folk songs. I loved this film at the cinema and repeat viewings on dvd have backed this up; its mixture of comedy and pathos, romance, phonesex and smashed up patio doors is genuinely appealing. The cast are perfect, and Sandler is a revelation playing something approaching his typical 'manchild', but cast adrift in a world that frustrates and frightens him. Emily Watson brings a tender soulfulness to the character of Lena, and Philip Seymour-Hoffman is as great as ever playing Barry's nemesis the Mattress Man. Punch-Drunk Love split the critics when released and falls into the 'love it or hate it' category pretty squarely. But if you can accept the uneven tone and want something wholly different from the usual pap that Hollywood serves up in the romantic comedy genre you may well be surprised and delighted. And watch out for the way Barry's ties change colour as the film progresses to match the colour of Lena's dress last time he saw her. Aint that sweet?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
a P.T. Anderson film., 25 Jun 2010
This review is from: Punch-Drunk Love [DVD] [2010] (DVD)
It's taken me a really long time (and multiple viewings) to realise that I really like this film a lot. Adam Sandler brings a lot to this role (and is perfect for it) but he also brings a lot of unwanted stuff regarding the expectations you might have going into an Adam Sandler film. The first time I saw this I had some very different expectations to what I ended up seeing here. I'll be honest I was slightly dissapointed.
I watched it again after seeing P. T. Anderson's next film `There Will Be Blood' (which has been my favorite film since I saw it in the cinema) and I realized how much I love the it. It's taken me a while to get there but now I'm totally there. And compared to TWBB it really is a really P. T. Anderson film. The protagonist is a flawed but likeable character. How you feel about him changes throughout the film. I like my protagonists flawed I've realized. And I don't like them to come through a whole heap of trouble and emerge a normal person at the other end.
I'd say the biggest similarity between the two films has to do with the concept of love and companionship. This is the central theme underlying both of these films. There is a line in PDL; "I have a love in my life and that makes me stronger than you can possibly imagine". Barry's life is made worth living by having someone to love and share himself with. It's only when he begins a relationship that he starts to take care of himself physically, by standing up to the people who would harm his new love, or his ability to be with her. This is a newly found central relationship in his life, which carries incredible significance for him. Similarly Daniel Plainview in TWBB has a central relationship upon which he builds his entire life around. It's only when his Brother comes to stay does can he get rid of his problematic son. And it's only when his brother betrays him (I don't want to spoil it) does he need to get his son back to him. He needs a family member to depend on, run his business and share his life with. This is why Plainview is so twisted at the end of the film when his son, In his eyes, betrays him. Both characters have a deep need for companionship. In my eyes this is obviously a theme, unconscious or not, from P. T. Anderson.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best romantic movie of the last ten years, 10 Oct 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: Punch-Drunk Love [DVD] [2010] (DVD)
After the hugely successful Boogie Nights and the inspirational Magnolia, it seems P.T. Anderson has written and directed yet another astonishingly genius movie that goes way off the richter scale of the normal, and all the better for it.Punch-Drunk Love is the Adam Sandler/"romantic comedy" in essence, but hugley distorted and a lot more subtle in humour, making it a truly surreal experience.Adam Sandler stars as Barry Egan, the "Angry but innocent" archetype, but made a lot more realistic and human.So rather than just shouting and stomping like in so many other Sandler films, Barry is quiet,depressed,obsessed with repeating patterns and is prone to outbursts of violence because of a serious implosive rage issue.Barry is the boss of a small company that sells toiletries, is emotionally scarred by his nagging seven sisters, is used to being put down all the time and is very, very lonely. So lonely infact that he calls a phone sex line, just so he can talk to somebody. This leads to a sleazy extortion scam lead by the big talking Mattress Man(played by Philip Seymour Hoffman) and threats Barry's well being. Then enters the unusually beautiful Lena(Emily Watson) who strikes up an unassuming relationship with Barry, just because she saw him in a photograph one of his sisters took and decided to take a chance. Their love blossoms and sends Barry into a state of emotional complexity, fluctuating between lust, uncontrollable rage(at everyone else except Lena anyway) and self doubt,ultimately leading him to change his hellish life and confront the extortionists out to get him. I, like everybody, was a bit sceptical of Adam Sandler being in P.T. Andersons movie, but after seeing the film I realise that he is one of the best actors of our time. He manages to be funny and very sympathetic as the emotional mess that is our hero, while Hoffman,Watson and Luis Guzman excell as the rest of the cast. What also is outstanding is the directing, beautifully shot images full of extreme colours.The use of sound is amazing too, as the tense drum music builds up when Barry is getting verbally abused,underpressure or growing more wildly angry, but when he is around Lena, its only triumphant violin music and a strange version of Shelly Duvall singing "He Needs Me"(as seen from the live version of Popeye). Punch-Drunk Love won the best direcitng award at the Cannes and deserves to be a success.Definitely not a movie to miss if you want to see a unique, emotionally powerful love story with a twist.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|