Paula Bartley's examination of nineteenth century prostitution could have been a useful book for the student of social history or women's studies. It is most unfortunate that it is spoilt by generalisations that are unsupported, and, in some cases, inaccuracies. As a researcher in the same area, I found several examples of comments about a particular religious community which were simply wrong, something Ms Bartley could not have known without access to primary sources - lack of such access should have resulted in the omission of the conclusions being drawn about that Community, but Ms Bartley chose to go ahead and state her opinion as fact. Similarly she uses her knowledge of some religious communities to generalise about religious provision for the "rescue" of "fallen" women: this is most misleading since the C19th communities each had their own rules and were not a united body. Ms Bartley gives unwarranted weight to the role of the clergy in religious Houses of Mercy (as such places were usually called), she does not note that community chaplains were actually employed by the community, not by the Church, and quite a large number of communities did carry out their work in direct opposition to the local clergy and the diocesan bishops. Ms Bartley does give some useful statistical information, for example, on the role of the Church Penitentiary Association, a real time saver for the student. I have commented particularly on her comments on the work of religious women dealing with prostitutes, the book also covers other areas of provision, the laws relating to prostitutes, and other matters not relating to religious communities. Unfortunately there is little new in this material, although the student may need to consult more than one work to collate it all. Overall, despite the usefulness of some of the material as mentioned and in a few other areas, this is not a book I would recommend to a student of the social, religious, or women's history in the C19th. There are several other writers' whose work pre-dates Ms Bartley's but surpass it in quality and scholarship. It is an impressive attempt to cover a subject many find difficult to discuss; unfortunately the attempt does not live up to the status of some of Ms Bartley's earlier work.