I watched this on television when it was released a few Christmases ago, and thought it was just incredible. Macmillan's choreography is passionate and perfect, the costumes and staging are gorgeous, and I think in terms of dramatic intensity it is unrivalled, because the drama is sustained so well by the supporting cast and the corps de ballet as well as the two leads. The dancers Jose Martin (Mercutio) and Thiago Soares (Tybalt) are very, very good, as are Laura Morera, Isabel McKeekan and Sian Murphy, as the street harlots. Christopher Saunders and Elizabeth McGorian are also convincing as Lord and Lady Capulet, as is Sandra Conley as the nurse.
Carlos Acosta is a great Romeo. His dancing is wonderful, both powerful and graceful. His acting is also great; he is dashing, light-hearted, warm and volatile, breezing about in the market place with the harlots and his friends. He seems laid back and even a bit naïve as Romeo, falling in love with Juliet at the ball without really grasping how dangerous it could be for them. Then he kills Tybalt in a fit of righteous anger after Mercutio's murder, and seems to become more sombre by the third act; and just disbelieving and heartbroken in the tomb scene when he finds Juliet seemingly dead. I think his portrayal was really incredible.
Tamara Rojo, meanwhile, is a warm, wonderful Juliet. She is a brilliant dancer and actress. I heard she had studied Shakespeare's text for dancing the part, and it seems to show. Her reading of Juliet is as someone passionate, serious, deep and sensitive, and her Juliet's love for Romeo is (initially) portrayed in just the quiet, contained way you'd expect from Shakespeare's Juliet - even though her eyes are brimming with excitement and she is smiling with secret joy. But her acting is especially moving during the third act, as she is repulsed at her family's forcing her to marry Paris, then seeming to hear demons at her ear before taking the friar's potion. Her final, silent scream at the tomb scene is also really harrowing, and the first time I watched it, my eyes welled up a bit. In terms of dancing, I think she danced the part really beautifully and there is so much elegance, dignity and grace in her dancing. Tamara Rojo reminds me a bit of Margot Fonteyn, who featured in the first DVD of the ballet.
But this is a wonderful version of the ballet, and I do recommend it. :)