Having lapped up Edsel's original-master-tapes CD editions of "Quick Step" and "Into The Gap" (never been a big fan of "Future Days") I was always hoping they might risk the less commercial early material - and they've come up with the goods. Although individual packaging would've been nice, as neither of these albums are likely to sell anywhere near as much as the later pop material I can see why they've combined both into one budget reissue. At least they didn't try and cram both albums on 1 disc, but have given us both complete albums and the vast majority of related extended mixes/ b-sides etc (including some great rarities like the "Big Value/Super Synthesised" mix of "In The Name of Love" and the b-side tracks from the freebie 7" that came with some copies of "Set" LP).
Artwork is traditional booklet format, rather than the fold-out poster, and I prefer this as it won't get creased - and the liner notes give enough information about both albums to satisfy most fans (old and new).
But there is a catch...this time round Edsel are a little vague about how they are sourced/mastered (CD 'Mastering' only, no reference to sourced from Master Tapes - except the Big Value remix which refers to Tape - or any Remastering). There is a reason for this - most of the bonuses (at least) on CD1 are from vinyl, and unfortunately obviously so in the case of the early 7" only material. This was initially a bit of a shock, bearing in mind the other Thompson Twins releases, and the pressings are not always the best quality. On CD2 the first few bars of "In The Name of Love" include rumble that sounds a bit like vinyl source, and there are occasional split/distorted hi-hat/crashes on other tracks, so this could be the case here too. However the extras on this disc are much generally much better sound quality than on CD1.
These are early and hence rougher recordings, so transfer to CD was never going to be easy, but potential buyers need to make up their own minds before parting with their vinyl originals. Importantly the mastering is sympathetic, and doesn't kill the music by trying to filter out all of the vinyl surface noise, where it exists.
So 5 out of 5 for issuing these albums on CD, with so much extra material, but 3 out of 5 for not making it clear what source formats were used. Hence average 4 out of 5, as this 'Product' is still good musically!
I too would like "Close To Bone" and "Big Trash" (with all the extras available) issued, maybe also as a double like this (as that will make the package more attractive to fans who haven't heard their later material before they went more dance-orientated). But from Master tapes please :-)