I enjoyed 'Problem Solved' for several reasons. It is incredibly well written and is very engaging. The editorial offers a marked change from most books in this category that, I find, tend to be written in a style that is so impenetrable and up itself, it subsequently elevates the role of the designer/art director to that of a Messiah - a panacea for all problems.
Secondly, I applaud Johnson's decision to show design with advertising to illustrate the book's main themes. And the design work chosen isn't the de rigour award-winning stuff that turns up in most graphics books, but good
creative work that also had success from a marketing point of view.
The previous reviewer mentioned that the book failed to be robust in it's analysis of the creative work featured in the book. I personally didn't feel this, as surely the aim of the text is to examine a particular genre of problem solving and showcase the work that fits this type in order for the
reader to recognise how one particular problem i.e. 'the astonish me' problem' was solved by a clutch of creative practices that specialise in different disciplines and ways of working.
I have found that is is rare that designer/art director can articulate a deep insight into the strategy of the work, I usually go to the planner or marketing director for that point of view.
I can see how the design elite would be offended by this book as it does have a strong marketing bias and, although many designers/art director may say that they are 'problem solvers', at heart many prefer to experiment with their creative skills. Hence the number of designers who prefer to design books but complain about the low fees and the number of agency art directors who call their commercials films.
Ultimately the book is a good read and is a pragmatic solution to presenting the point where design, advertising and marketing meet. A point which still makes many creative people uncomfortable. It looks good too.