I would start by saying that Mr. Carothers is a man of God with a heart for people and has definitely been used by God. Parts of this book clearly reveal this. However, it is also clear, especially in the latter parts of the book, that he has come under demonic deception. I have been a Christian for many years and I have personally experienced demonic deception. Let me illustrate with some examples.
In Chapter 7, the author said that the Holy Spirit ordered him to get out of bed! He later threatened that if he wouldn't learn a lesson in the bathroom, He would make him learn the lesson by forcing him to go back to bed and there, immobilise him!! Quite simply, God NEVER does these things. He does not take an aggressive domineering attitude with us. As soon as I read this and other parts, immediately warning bells that something was wrong started to ring.
Later, it said that he had been having headaches for several years and one day, God allegedly asked him why he had not thanked God FOR the headaches. He continued to praise God FOR giving him the pain and then suddenly there was a break-through. The suggestion was that by praising God FOR giving him pain, relief came. Nowhere in the Bible are we asked to thank God FOR bad things but we are asked to give thanks to God IN all situations (1 Thessalonians 5:18). I believe that demons, including an evil spirit of pain, successfully persuaded him to twist the scriptural meaning from IN to FOR. The demons went to all this trouble because they want people to think that God deliberately causes them pain which naturally, makes having a relationship with God very difficult (as Carothers witnessed in people when he told them to give thanks to God FOR causing pain). The correct Biblical understanding is that we give thanks to God IN all situations and pray for deliverance from pain. Proof that it was demonic can be seen in his admission that he had been having these headaches for several years. God does not cause people pain for years in order to one day teach them a lesson!!
Furthermore, I have read a lot of books written by Christians in which God moves powerfully and sometimes miraculously in their lives. I have heard of God speaking a few words (especially of comfort to people in distress) but I have never read of Him entering into back and forth running conversations with us. Demons however, typically try to do just this such as when they work as deceiving spirits presenting themselves to unsuspecting people as kindly 'spirit guides' or 'loving angels'.
Quite simply, Mr. Carothers has been listening to deceiving demonic spirits as I think I have proven from the above examples. However, I would say here that many of his experiences, especially in the earlier part of the book, appear to be genuinely of God.
Should a reader want to expand his/her knowledge of the glories of God as revealed in the lives of ordinary men and women, try books such as: Chasing the Dragon by Jackie Pullinger, God's Smuggler by Brother Andrew, The Torn Veil by Gulshan Esther, Sergei by Sergei Kourdakov and Tramp for the Lord by Corrie Ten Boom.
Simon Forth