4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Far from Prickly!, 10 April 2007
This review is from: Prickly Pears of Palestine: The People Behind the Politics (Paperback)
Many of us have become inured to the seemingly never ending `eye for an eye' justice of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. We watch scenes of carnage on the television news: boys throwing stones at army tanks; black shrouded women wailing over ruined homes; victims being transported from the latest suicide bomb attack, and mentally switch off.
However, this book made me see the situation anew, through the eyes of the people who live here. The causes of the problem have often been forgotten through the mists of time, and a timely and succinct history of the conflict sets the scene for the stories of those who are living in the Holy Land of today. In talking to, rather than interviewing people, on all sides of the dispute, the author reveals an ear for dialogue and an eye for the absurd. One minute she is being asked to recite the text for conversion to Islam, the next, hands are being laid upon her to be saved by Jesus. It is certainly not a dry, boring text.
Never judgmental, Hilda allows the characters to speak for themselves, revealing the gaps in perspectives between the disparate groups. Christian Zionists; Muslims; secular Jews; `born again' Christians; orthodox Jews; settlers; families of suicide bombers - all have their say, illustrating the complexity as well as the humanity of the situation. Sometimes the situation seems hopeless, at other times there is a note of optimism.
But one thing is for certain; the television images of the strife in Palestine will no longer leave me unmoved. That in itself is the biggest reason why it should be widely read - as an antidote to indifference to the heartbreak of Palestine.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Sharp and fruitful -- Prickly Pears, 15 Feb 2007
This review is from: Prickly Pears of Palestine: The People Behind the Politics (Paperback)
This is a very vivid and easy to read introduction to the daily lives of people in Palestine for those of us who know about that troubled land only through the news. Reilly's friendships with the wide variety of people she met and her humanity enlighten and alleviate what is otherwise a grim story. She meets 'extremists' on both sides as well as ordinary people struggling to live a 'normal' life. Her conversational style makes us feel that we have met them too. Neither a journalist nor a voluntary or aid worker, Reilly remains a travel writer, who has chosen to write about a dangerous and difficult place and the people who live there. Her courage can be read through the lines of her account.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No