|
57 of 69 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Too american, no new ideas, give it a miss, 14 Feb 2005
I bought this book with an aim to find new and inexpensive ways to creatively entertain my toddler after seeing it mentioned as a good resource - this book was a big let down.Designed for the American market, i can get around the spelling differences, but constant reference to graham crackers, contact paper and other americanisms was the first irritation as i was having to semi translate back into english to understand the equipment necessary. This further extended to the over reliance on expensive materials for many activites, Golf balls, glue guns, zip lock bags i do not have on tap in my house. Then theres age appropriate activites, the book designed for ages 1.5-3 (audience reading you might jip) has constant reference to cutting with scissors, glueing - activiteis not able to be child led, going against the quote, "process not end product" as the child at that age most likely cannot do the activity even aided. Food section covers cooking with mostly peanut butter and honey -not thing srecommended generally for the younger part age group with a brief line on allergies. Rainy days is again 10 activites revolving around one idea, that being create a squishy mess in a zip lock bag. Water play is a bunch of activities using food colouring. Nursery rhymes -a list of common ones, covering another chapter. Rest of the chapters extended basic ideas of paint in various forms. Book list at back covers not commonly regarded english toddler books. It's often said "your child will enjoy" -meaning the authors american child enjoyed personally. My daughter would not be kept occupied (as suggested) in her cot whilst i showered in the morning with a basket of quiet toys. Neither at 1 in a high chair with a small box of raisins whilst I "worked". is this the american idea of 50s england? not a reality. Tempera paint (what is that?), popsickle sticks, card milk cartons - it'd be permenant translation and adaptation to another market. Ask your child the question "where does god sleep?" as an "out and about activity -this american idea of pre school support or home ed is too far removed for english parents to find practically useful on all levels. A huge disapointment beyond the basic level that the activites are nothing more than common sense to most intelligent parents used to small children. Suggest for more useful activites take a simple look around your home and outdoors and follow childs interests, perhaps looking at Dorothy Einon Creative Play or Teaching Montessori in the Home: Pre-school Years as a better resource.
|