1 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting., 13 Feb 2010
This review is from: Prague Noir: The Weeping Woman on the Streets of Prague (City Noir) (Paperback)
I have to say that I picked this up almost at random, just looking for something to break my usual flow, so I preceded with it despite it not having a precis, or any enlightening comments on the back as to what it was like or about.
It is essentially a very long (111 pages) ode to Prague, in a very lyrical form that can be hard to follow at times (maybe something to do with the French to English translation). I thought it extremely beautiful at times, with some wonderful poetic sentiments relating to loss and grief.
The 'story' seems to follow sightings of a mysterious woman who appears on the streets of Prague, usually at times of sadness and she somehow captures this sadness within her.
A problem I had with it, possibly from the lack of prior knowledge, is that I didn't know what type of book it was or was trying to be. In the back it lists itself as Noir/Travel Writing, not a combination one sees often, or that even applies to this book. It certainly isn't Noir in the conventional sense, it's magical and regularly quite light, so not Noir at all. I can just about see how it could be see as travel writing, as it is trying to capture the essence of the city. But really it is a long poem in prose form, written from the sounds of it while on a stay in the city, and the author was enamored with the city enough to try to capture it's essence.
It appears from a little research that Sylvie Germain is an author of note in France, but also that this book is a departure from her other work, and even lists this work as non-fiction, this may be the case but it felt pretty fictitious to me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No