I am currently learning French and German having mastered Spanish.
While Dorothy Richmond's Spanish Vocabulary is a veritable 400 word bonanza of words and helpful exercises, this one is a decided disappointment.
The Spanish one is twice it's size and is excellent value with plenty of thorough exercises to consolidate the lists of new words.
This French Vocabulary has lots of word lists but only four-five exercises per unit. The exercises themselves are not particularly thorough, requiring only true/false answers and very often requiring words that are not listed at all in the previous wordlist. A good workbook lists the vocabulary and then provides thorough exercises to practice and consolidate it, it does not confuse the student with yet a few more new words of which the meaning is not given.
You will therefore need a good dictionary at your side when using this book as you will meet many unfamiliar words in the exercises that have not been listed in the unit being practiced.
In my view, to improve this book the following would need to happen:
1. Exercise only the vocabulary being introduced. An efficient self contained workbook should not require a dictionary.
2. Expand the exercises beyond True/False, A-L lists and reading comprehension. Give writing tasks for example, and please give more exercises. A little more imagination please!! Take a look at Ms Deveney Richmond's Spanish series' for guidance.
I am not entirely ignorant of the issues at hand as I am a qualified adult education teacher myself!
Thanks.