The Possessed: Adventures with Russian Books and the People Who Read Them [Hardcover]

 

 

Create your own review

Elif Bauman is an American academic, from a Turkish family, who asks how she ended up spending seven years in California studying the Russian novel? In this book she talks about conferences she attended; such as one on Babel in California and another in Tolstoy's ancestral home. Also time she spent in Samarkand learning Uzbek, as well as other Russian visits and many other Russian authors. Actually though, what the book is about is her love affair with Russian literature and, as someone who shares her love for all things Russian, it is a joy to read. I adore books about books and Elif Bauman writes so well, with such humour and passion, that the book has become one of my favourites immediately and Bauman an author I hope I will hear (and read) much from.

Although a series of essays, Bauman has endless humourous stories to tell and she weaves her tales into those about the authors and books she loves, meandering delightfully off the point and having a wonderful sense of humour about all that befalls her on her travels. If you have an interest in Russia and a love of literature, then this book is for you. As for her original question about how she spent so long studying the Russian novel? Well, all I can say is that I am glad she did and I look forward to more from this extremely talented writer. An absolute joy and pleasure to read and I also learnt a lot. Highly recommended.

Elif Batuman's book of essays, The Possessed, loosely based on the joys of reading classic Russian literature, turns out to be a bit of a hodge-podge of travel-writing, literary criticism and a personal reading history, enlivened by a butterfly mind that flutters from one subject to another without really landing for too long on any particular theme.

This gives the book a distinct lack of unity - sure, some of it is brilliant, but at other times, this reader at least thought, yes, but this isn't really why I came here. The book is subtitled "Adventures with Russian Books and the People who Read Them", and in a loose way, I suppose that's fair enough, but I expected more unity of purpose, with more material written specifically for this book rather than a fair amount of bringing together previously published lectures and articles.

I've no problem with bringing together collections of previously published material, but I do think the publishers should make this clear on the cover because in this case at least, I could find quite a bit of the book online and find out whether it was something I wanted to read. As it is, the book is very selective in its appraisal of Russian books and the people who read them and hardly serves the purpose of its subtitle at all - in my humble opinion!

I wanted more, I suppose something like it says on the tin - a book about reading Russian literature, something more comprehensive, with a bit of planning behind it. I got instead large chunks about Batuman's intellectual and academic development including tortuous stories of how she ended up learning the Uzbek language, or how she moved from one course to another while at college. Dare I say, that some of it seemed remarkably self-congratulatory - a sort of "look how clever I am", but maybe that's my English perceptions getting in the way - American reviewers seem not to have picked up on this at all.

I got a pretty good essay on the Russian writer Isaac Babel, and a long lecture on The Death of Tolstoy which can be found online on the Harpers Magazine archive. Other items were previously published in the New Yorker and elsewhere. Sometimes you get elongated versions of other articles -for example, one chapter, The House of Ice builds on an article previously published in the New Yorker and is devoted telling the story of how in 2006 a replica of Empress Anna Ioannovna's ice palace built in St. Petersburg. Its all very interesting, a sort of first person travelogue, the sort of thing which would be published in Granta magazine, but its hard to see its how it fits into this book about Russian literature.

Three chapters are devoted to Batuman's time in Samarkand where she was learning the Uzbek language. Its all very funny and contains many amusing anecdotes such as how she learned to choose water-melons in the market by listening to them talk.

In the final chapter, Batuman visits Florence where Dostoevsky wrote The Idiot. She moves on to discuss his novel The Possessed and after summarising the book in a few pages, she immediately lost me by interpreting the book in the context of René Girard theory of "mimetic desire" which was apparently "formulated in opposition to the Nietzschean notion of autonomy as the key to human self-fulfilment".

Four or five pages of discussion of this theory then follow, after which Batuman recounts a little tale of how when she returned to Stanford the department's dynamics had completely changed as new people had arrived (including the charismatic Matej from Croatia) and others had left. We get four or five pages of the impact on these changes and a fair amount about Matej's impact on Batuman's life, but I can't for the life of me see how they relate to Dosteovsky's book The Possessed. But then Batuman's writing jumps around so much its just as I said at the start of this book, like following a butterfly as it moves from one plant to another. Its difficult to focus in on one particular topic before she's off on another one. I'd have had no problem with Girard's theory of mimetic desire in the midst of a book which had been leading up to it, but to just drop it into a chapter largely discussing relationships within her department reads like a first-year female student at University who's reading her text books while eyeing up the boy at the next table.

I'm very disappointed with this book. Its lack of focus and structure completely detracts from some of the good things it includes. It seems a cheap way of putting a book together to me and if it had been subtitled "assorted writings of Elif Batuman" I wouldn't have bothered with it. The lure of reading about "the Russian literature reading experience" misled me in this case and I wouldn't recommend this book unless you're already into Batuman's work.

I was excited about reading this book, being a Russian literature enthusiast (or should that be obsessive?) myself. I was slightly disappointed though as the realisation soon dawned that this book is, at best, three parts personal memoir and one part discussion of the wonder and uniqueness of Russian literature. Elif Batuman is a good writer, and her anecdotes about meeting Isaac Babel's eccentric wife and daughter, or going on a bizarre summer stay to Uzbekistan, are never less than engaging, and often very funny.

But, I think the book has been sneakily marketed as something which it is not; by the half way point, I think, there had been a handful of mentions of Tolstoy, and a tale of an academic conference related stay at his home, and some passing references to Pushkin, Babel (not really one of the greatest), and Dostoyevsky. The book does not in fact explore Russian books much at all - it mentions them in the context of the author's adventures, and as such, the emphasis is heavily on the adventures of a young Turkish woman in America and the former USSR, following her own path in life and describing the people she meets (the majority of whom do not seem to read Russian books!), not the books themselves. 'Possessed' is therefore frustrating if you want to gain many insights or fresh perspectives on most of the great Russian writers, and is better approached simply as a memoir which will occasionally mention some works you may know, or plan to read.

Overall, a little bit underwhelming.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 10 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

1.0 out of 5 stars If you want to turn children away from literature, force this on them.
You know, Mikhail Bulgakov's The Master and Margarita, yes, that one, if you enjoyed that, please don't read this. If you like Chekhov or Dickens, this is not for you. Read more

Published 1 month ago by Ade

5.0 out of 5 stars Russian literature and a summer in Samarkand
I knew very little about Russian literature so I thought this could be an interesting book to read and I did find It interesting reading if not for the reasons I'd expected. Read more

Published 4 months ago by Damaskcat

1.0 out of 5 stars Diabolically disappointing
For readers who love Tolstoy, Pushkin, Turgenev and the other greats of Russian literature - or for people who have travelled to Russia and love the country - there is little of... Read more

Published 8 months ago by Chandler

4.0 out of 5 stars Good fun and a bit challenging
This is an entertaining - often slyly funny - account of the life of a would-be novelist who has to find an alternative career as in linguistics or literary education. Read more

Published 8 months ago by E. Clarke

5.0 out of 5 stars Be the first on your block
This is a wonderful read - which I don't intend to spoil for you - and Granta have done it proud in this stonking new *hardback* edition; 'would grace any bookshelf' as they say... Read more

Published 10 months ago by Simon G. Barrett

5.0 out of 5 stars Hilarious, extremely well written -- for Russophiles who've been there and done that
I was very curious about this book when it started cropping up on my Librarything (an interest site where you can catalogue the books in your personal library and browse other... Read more

Published 18 months ago by mab

3.0 out of 5 stars Interesting idea, but not enlightening
If you're looking for an enlightening essay on Russian literature stay away from this book.

However, is a well written collection of essays about Elif Batuman's... Read more

Published 18 months ago by M. G. Azevedo

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 10 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!