The Poetry Handbook (Paperback)

This new edition (it’s blue) is porkier than its predecessor, which is great for the ordinary enthusiastic reader like me: it's got even more delicious ingredients, more poems, more ingenious readings that are none the less NAILED to the texts. So for the ordinary reader Blue Lennard is porkier in a good way. Buy Blue Lennard because you enjoyed Red Lennard.
For the teacher Blue Lennard is very obviously an improvement on what was already a good textbook: there are exercises at the end of each chapter and many more examples. For a teacher running a class it's a technically a much better sausage for being porkier.
But if you are a student and nobody seems to want to teach you actually to do practical criticism, then get hold of a Red Lennard second hand, read it, google the referenced poems and in a week you will be so much better at Practical Criticism that you'll never have to download a lousy essay again. Then buy tis second edition and read it for fun.
I suppose I think that for the student on their own, Blue Lennard may be porkier in a bad way, because it is double the size, even cleverer, and even more confidently witty than Red Lennard, so maybe not so useful in an emergency. Red Lennard was a speed boat disguised as a life raft; blue Lennard is an aircraft carrier which will improve the teaching of practical criticism wherever it is deployed, and I suspect will simply redefine what can be expected of the students if they are properly taught. Blue Lennard will be hegemonic and will be a goldmine for the OUP and John Lennard.
Inside Blue Lennard, the spine of a thin man wildly signalling inside fat man, the speedboat inside the life raft that has been eaten by the aircraft carrier, is the original core of Red Lennard, an analysis of Derek Walcott’s Nearing Forty, tied to each chapter of the text. This is a detective story that let’s you follow the younger Lennard make a series of fascinating discoveries with his humane but forensic approaches: Cracker. In making Blue Lennard hegemonic, this fascinating detective work (every word of which remains in Blue Lennard but no longer as a spine) gets lost. Red Lennard said to the engaged reader: “read this forensic manual and you will be able to have adventures like I had with Nearing Forty”. Blue Lennard will have lots more (maybe ten times more, but the sky’s the limit: every student of English in the world should have The Poetry Handbook) but less-engaged readers who will become much better at reading and writing and much better at Practical Criticism. The Benthamite calculus is that Blue Lennard will do more good to a hugely greater number than did Red Lennard, but the average amount of good done per reader will be less. “You must read this book because it sets and exposits the standard of practical criticism that will be expected in this department of English”.
Red Lennard changed my life. It was a completely creative book that just looked like a manual. Blue Lennard will sell in far greater numbers because it is a much better textbook even than Red Lennard was, and it will by in that way have far more leverage and make many more students more articulate and alive through their reading. I just hope their teachers draw to their attention Lennard’s account of his inspiring adventures with Nearing Forty.