Nowhere is the dichotomy of The Replacements more evident than on their second major label effort: Pleased To Meet Me.
A poisoned valentine to the music industry, the record's title and cover swipe at the kind of smug gladhanding they abhorred, and would go to often insanely self-destructive lengths to avoid, (from playing a crucial record company showcase at CBGBs too drunk to stand, to allegedly stealing and throwing the master tapes of their early albums into the Minneapolis River when they heard of plans to release them on CD format).
The pose of PTMM ranges from self-doubt, as on Nevermind, where frontman Paul Westerberg drily notes "I suppose your guess is more or less as bad as mine", to the all-out rejection of the mainstream of I Don't Know, where he disdains "The sweet smell that you adore... I think I'd rather smother." Yet the album is full of the kind of stadium rock anthems that surely deserved to make them one of the biggest bands on the planet.
Chief among these are Can't Hardly Wait, a gorgeous pop-rock strut which, mixed with Westerberg's trademark sardonic attitude recalls Randy Newman being backed by the E Street Band; and the soaring Alex Chilton, where Westerberg celebrates the eponymous Big Star frontman, painting him as a kind of indie rock Ziggy Stardust.
The Ledge comes on musically like U2's menacing younger sibling, and for it's dark tale of suicide, Westerberg proves he is ever-capable of switching wiseass attitude for emotionally direct, empathetic lyricism.
I.O.U., Shooting Dirty Pool and Red Red Wine all have a Stonesy clatter, while Skyway is more Beatles, a delicate, ethereal ballad. Nightclub Jitters provides the records other oasis of calm, as the 'Mats get smoky and seductive with a late night, jazz club affair.
Detractors of the album tend to focus on the absence of founder guitarist Bob Stinson, but while I can admire his playing, I don't really miss him on those later 'Mats records. While he was an important part of their youthful, chaotic makeup, he was basically a musical conservative who just wanted to keep kicking out the punk jams. The way the band parted company with him is undoubtedly tragic in hindsight, but I think keeping him around would have hurt what they eventually became. PTMM shows them as a band that can do it all.
There's enough good stuff in this special edition to make it worth a purchase, even if you own the original, I think. Birthday Gal is a melancholic, acoustically strummed pop gem, probably my favourite 'Mats non-album track. Election Day's raw blues is a protest song only they would write, (it sucks because you can't find anywhere to buy booze). Cool Water features a genuinely affecting vocal performance from Westerberg, full of yearning and unexpected country twang. Route 66 and Tossin' and Turnin' are sloppy takes on classic rock 'n' roll, almost certainly recorded while drunk, but also good fun.