Ok,so the first question is,Who will buy this release?
I'm sure it's aimed at long time fans AND first time buyers but do we really need another Enigma best of?
Here's the pros and the cons.
It is the third Enigma collection released in the last nine years.The first being "
Lsd - Love Sensuality and Devotion [Digipak]" and it's accompanying "
Best of Remixes" collection,both released in 2001.The second collection was the mammoth 8 disc "15 Years After" containing 6 cd's(5 official studio releases and one bonus disc of re-recordings produced by Rollo) and 2 dvd's("MCMXC A.D." dvd video with the entire album in dts/Dolby surround and "Remember The Future" dvd video collection).A very lavish and expensive coffee table book style edition released in 2005 and now very rare "
15 Years After: +2dvd".
Now we have "The Platinum Collection".A three disc set that,unlike the former Greatest Hits Collections presents all of Enigma's single releases as stand alone tracks instead of the now familiar continuous mix that all previous albums have.
Disc one contains the single/radio versions,disc two contains the extended/remix tracks and disc three(The Lost Ones),which I feel most Enigma fans will buy this set for,contains eleven "lost" tracks that are all new releases.But don't get too excited.There is not a lot of new music here for the long time fan."The Lost Ones" disc clocks in at only 35 minutes.There are a few other tracks that make a cd debut here on disc one.Most hardcore Enigma fans will already have these tracks on various single releases but anyone new to Enigma would be better served by the previous best of release(L.S.D.) that is a musical montage not simply a collection of radio hits.Only one track on disc two makes a cd debut."Dreaming Of Andromeda-JF Cochois Remix" previously only available on digital download or dvd,the rest are all reissues,most of which are also on the last collection.
EMI have been releasing Platinum Collections for some of their better known artists such as Roxy Music,Queen and Mike Oldfield to name a few.These collections have very extensive booklets that contain all the relevant info on each track.The booklet that comes with this Enigma collection is very sparse and short on detail.Another con for this release.I took off a star because of the cheap packaging and the use of the same cover artwork,albeit slightly modified,that was utilised for "15 Years After".
So summing up,for hardcore fans,there are some slim pickings.For new fans it's a great collection for the price but to truly experience the Enigma sound-scape I would advise listening to the aforementioned best of releases or any of the 7 full length albums.
My personal favourites are "
The Cross of Changes " and "
The Screen Behind the Mirror " but a good place to start is "
MCMXC A.D.".
Turn off the light,take a deep breath and relax.....