In writing Planet Simpson, author Chris Turner risked turning himself into The Simpsons' anal Comic Book Guy - with his clipped nasal tones - investing far too much of his time and energy into what is simply a pretty crude cartoon: "Best. Cartoon. Ever." However, what makes The Simpsons different to, say, The Flintstones, it's prehistoric ancestor, is that The Simpsons is (A) hilarious and (B) an acutely observed portrait of a struggling, conflicted and yet in its own way, harmonious, nuclear family, deeply embedded in small town America.
Turner divides his analysis into sections - some look at the archetypal characters, such as (my personal favourite), captain of industry Charles Montgomery Burns and his bootlick, Smithers; the look at Burns will feature his cinematic precedents, such as Citizen Kane and It's a Wonderful Life; then the book might cast its gaze over what Monty might have to say about American-style capitalism ("Get beaten by the Japanese?! What, those sandal-wearing goldfish tenders? Pah!"). Other characters considered in detail include the main Simpson family of course. Naturally, the best section is on Homer, the most irritating is on Lisa.
Planet Simpson also breaks The Simpsons cartoon down into epochs, of which Turner argues there are three: the first is The Early Years, the first couple of series when the cartoon was still finding its feet, the animation was sketchy, voices were different and the humour was broader; the second epoch is The Golden Years, when the cartoon really hit its stride - this lasted until roughly season eight or nine; then we hit the final epoch, which we are still in, as of this writing: The Great Plateau, whereby we find that The Simpsons, whilst still being much funnier than most other sitcoms, is not really breaking any new ground but simply ploughing a well-worn furrow.
Chris Turner has written an audacious book, in Planet Simpson; it mixes one part fanboy celebration, with one part academic thesis and it is of course, peppered with hilarious quotes! Best cartoon ever? Well, I personally prefered Futurama...