There are obvious problems caused by the choice of band name here and you can see the headlines already, "Tired album", or "Load of pony" for example. Would there be any justification in this? To a certain extent yes but overall no.
Firstly I don't consider this to be a "country" album. It is too like Snow Patrol for that. You know the nagging chord sequences, the straightforward and repetitive vocal style, the gradual crescendo by the end of the song as extra instruments join in, you know the score if you know Snow Patrol. So why bother listening?
Well simply put it is rather good. For all the well worn criticism's of Lightbody's style, and he sticks to this template pretty much all the way through as I say above, it has to be said that he has a way with a melody, catchy singalong choruses and the aforementioned crescendos. They may all be a bit formulaic but they work so why change a winning formula? Of course this is all grist to a critic's mill so is there anything here that breaks the mould?
And the answer is yes. A couple of "proper" country (more alt-country really) tracks are included, and very welcome they are as well. "Point me at lost islands" is a chugalong effort with a hint of mandolin, whilst "Dead American Writers" introduces a slice of slide guitar. "I am the landslide" is a bit Neil Youngy and "The good book"s subject matter is definitely "country" Otherwise this is an album that will appeal more to Snow Patrol fans than REM's but isn't as bad as some media critics have made out.