How do you write a disappointing swashbuckler about pirates? Sadly, Perez-Reverte's latest tends to show us.
There's plenty of incident and action. Many of the scenes - a desperate attempt by galleys to break through enemy ships, a tense dawn waiting for a chance to ambush English raiders - are well drawn and convey genuine excitement, but too many do not. Even the climactic battle seems a bit half baked, as if the author lost faith in his ability to portray it properly part way through.
More problematic still is the lack of any strong narrative link between its various episodes. Much as The Sun Over Breda suffered from being little more than a collection of anecdotes about the war in Flanders, so this too amounts to little more than a series of events all involving acts of piracy and raiding. It might be appropriate for a tale of picaroons that the story is told in picaresque style, but sadly it reduces it, without anything more, like history, to just one damn thing after another.
I've enjoyed this series, but this book I found hard to finish - other, more tightly written, better books distracted me. That's a shame, because I had had high hopes for this.
Those who have stuck with the series this far are likely to want to read it anyway. For them there is a new character, who seems destined to be permanent part of the continuing stories, and a change in the relationship between Alatriste and Inigo. Those who have not read other episodes would be best advised to start elsewhere.