Anyone expecting a coherent third instalment of the Pirate's series will likely be very disappointed!
All the ingredients are here yet the finished product doesn't quite work. It's like the whole is LESS than the sum of the parts.
The start of the story revolves around finding Jack and bringing him back from Davy Jones' locker which ultimately leads to one of the oddest scenes I've scene in recent film history! I think the only reason this film works at all is because of Johnny Depp. His portrayal of Jack Sparrow (sorry, CAPTAIN Jack Sparrow) is very watchable and he's just so funny in this film. Everyone else is merely supporting him in various states of wooden-ness. Sorry but Orlando just doesn't cut it in this film, nor does Kiera. Sure they both look pretty but neither can hold a torch to Johnny Depp who's quite clearly having a ball. Of course that's just my opinion.
So why 4 stars? Well, however I turn it I can't help but enjoy the film for all it's faults. If you switch your brain off and don't take it too seriously, which, let's face it, won't be too hard then the film is thoroughly enjoyable. The story is all over the show and the twists and turns come thick and fast and I found it impossible to figure out who's crossing who most of the time!
The cast is top notch though apart from the two offenders I mentioned earlier :p. The two pirates from the first two films (the one with the wooden eye and his pal) provide plenty of comedy relief when Johnny Depp isn't running the show.
Being on Bluray the picture quality is simply outstanding. The detail level on a full HD set is simply incredible - these discs really are fantastic when done correctly. It's like the jump from VHS to DVD all over again for me. The resolution is so high that when you see film grain, like you do in this film, it's because the disc authors intend you to see it to retain the more organic feel of the original film stock, not because the media can't actually output a pristine clear picture like older formats. There's an uncompressed 5.1 PCM soundtrack which seems louder and more punchy than the standard Dolby Digital 5.1. Both are great and round out the top class presentation.
A separate mention must also be made of the special effects which are really top class throughout the film. Especially on Davy Jones himself who displays incredible detail. Full HD really lets you enjoy them to the max.
So all in all if you like the Pirates film as I do then buy it without reservation. There will be something here to please you although it's not, I feel, as good as it could have been!