I have to say this atlas was a little disappointing, but perhaps it was silly of me to expect it to be so much better than the National Geographic or The Times atlases in the first place. Having said that, it is supposed to be £50 cheaper than The Times, which would be a redeeming factor if discount book retailers did not exist. The fact is that due to discounts, both the Nat Geo and The Times atlases can be purchased cheaper than this one on Amazon, at least at the moment.
The maps of the atlas-proper are easy to read and aesthetically pleasing. In typical George Philip fashion, they are very good topographically, but somewhat lacking toponymically when compared to Nat Geo. However, they will more than suffice for ordinary browsing.
It has a very comprehensive supplementary section, with thematic maps, satellite photos of major cities and city maps, but I would trade them for more detailed world maps.
The index is superior to Nat Geo's and more or less on par with The Times, since it includes geographical co-ordinates.
Thumbs down for having it printed in Malaysia to increase profit margins / save money. This is a kick in the teeth for the British printing industry.
In conclusion, this atlas fell short of my expectations, and could be vastly improved by:
- increasing the scale of many of the maps
- including more detail of place names, former or alternative place names and disputed territories; this may require an additional 50 pages or so, or increasing the size of the pages themselves
- having it printed in its country of publication - England, rather than offshoring for the sake of a quid
The best atlas on the market, in my opinion, is still The Times (and even that is not perfect), but this will be good enough for most.