This book has a lot to like. First, there's the metal itself - silvery (modern alloys hold their shine), very affordable, and hugely workable. I have some expereince raising copper and silver, and would love to get back to forging. Then, the author gives a great intro to the working techniques unique to pewter. It forms easily and doesn't need annealing, since its annealing temperature is below room temperature. It solders and even welds at temperatures far below silver and such. Mandel's tip about bismuth-tin solder sounds interesting, too, since its melting point is far less than pewter's - a fact appealing to anyone who's melted a workpiece while hard soldering. The "gallery" aspect of this book offers plenty of inspiration to a wide range of tastes, too.
Still, I found this book somewhat frustrating. After showing how easily pewter can be formed using a modest and accessible set of tools, her first three projects all involve a hydraulic press - not something you see in every hobbyist's workshops, or even in most small professional studios. I find her use of an oxy-gas torch on pewter startling, too. That flame can melt metals at 2000F and up, so seems like overkill for something a soldering iron can weld. (I'll have to try it myself and see if the fineness of the flame mitigates its intense heat, but I expect to melt a lot of practice pieces.) I know that retailers come and go, but the bismuth-tin alloy is a bit exotic - a pointer to Rotometals d.o.t com would have been welcome. And the index? Don't bother.
So, my impression ends up thoroughly mixed. Mandel clearly knows her subject, and offers many valuable pointers, like the importance of avoiding cross-contamination with your other metlawork. Her sections on technique seem easy to follow, despite lack of obvious connection between text and photos (would it have been so hard to number them?). On the other hand, she seems to have forgotten what kind of tools a beginner is likely to have access to. This book offers the best intro I know to this wonderful metal, but it could have been a lot better.
-- wiredweird