The first adaptation of Peter Pan I saw was the Disney's version. While I did kind of like it, it did not stay true to the book that much. When I read the book, writen by J. M. Barrie, I really loved it, and wanted the film to reflect the book. Then the live action film came out in 2003. I expected it to be like the Disney version, untrue to the book, so I tried to avoid it. But curiosity got the better of me, so I waited it to come out on DVD and then riskly bought it. Oh Boy!!! was I proven wrong. In the end I had no regrets in purchasing it. I found it much truer to the book than the Disney version.
Everyone should know the story of the boy who did not want to grow up, so I won't give you a synopsis. What made the film even better was the cast that was chosen. Jeremy Sumpter as Peter Pan was brilliant. He was brilliantly chosen. His attitude and his facial expressions were wonderful, as was his acting. Rachel Hurd-Wood was equally as impressive as Wendy Darling. The actors who played Wendy's brothers were wonderful (though they had a small role, they had their moments, especially John, but Michael also had some, with his Teddy). Olivia Williams (Sixth Sense) was well cast as the mother. I loved all the pirates (especially Smee, played wonderfully by Richard Briers). But the actor who truly stole the film, in my own opinion, was Jason Isaacs. He is perfectly casted as both the father, Mr. Darling and Captain Hook. As the father, he is timid, kind of insecure, yet a father who dearly loves his family. And Isaacs really brings that out. But he plays hook with even more vileness. This is where he truly shines as an actor. Isaacs is well known for playing the baddie (see him in 'The Patriot', and as Mr. Malfoy, in the 'Harry Potter' films), and he does it so well. Watching him battle it out with Sumpter is spectacle to watch, they act so well together. And I'd like to add, Isaacs exit to the film was a classic!!!! I laughed at his facial expression as he went (I won't tell you how, in case you have not seen it), it made me laugh.
I also have to comment on the CGI effects. It was brilliantly done. Neverland has never looked so beautiful and realistic. And the flying sequence was brilliant and very well done. For a film to be good the directing (and the director) has to be good. P.J. Hogan (the director) did a brilliant job. He and his crew really did wonders with Neverland, and the film in general. My hats off to them!!!! With the brilliant actors, great directing and the CGI effects made this a brilliant movie.