Without a doubt the best Anthrax album so far. Among the Living is a classic and is awesome and will always be thought of as superior (a la Iron Maiden's Number of the Beast), but technically it pales in comparison to Persistence. Everything came together for this release. State of Euphoria was great, not as great as Among, but lacked a certain edge. Persistence truly sounds like a band at the top of their game, making great music because they've got to get these songs out of their head. They gel perfectly and all sound comfortable, older, more seasoned. Yes it sounds like they're getting all serious and boring - serious yes, boring no - but age and experience is a great recipe for success. However there is still a playfulness that interweaves throughout, as on 'Got the Time', one of the most frenetic and truly bonkers and truly flawless metal songs written (think 'Chop Suey' by System of a Down ish) and the wonderfully thrashy closer, 'Discharge'.
The change here is the heaviness is ramped up and the thrash is toned down. They no longer can be called thrash (the same goes for Metallica, in my humble), just a damned good heavy metal outfit. Just take the opener, 'Time'. It does indeed take its time - which is another great aspect: they are not afraid to let the song grow and make its own way, not scared to put the listener off - but it almost feels like it creates itself as chunks of verse come building up to chunks of chorus, accompanied by a primal drumbeat throughout the entire duration of the track marking each milestone like a hammer knocking in rivets. 'Blood' is another behemoth, only in a more traditional sense. Great chorus, very chunky sound, everything seems tightened to the nth degree. 'Keep it in the Family'is a triumph of song-writing. For a 'thrash' band it is painfully plodding but the guitars sound so beautiful, round and deep and enveloping. It is one of their best. What follows is just more of the same excellence. 'In My World' is an epic sounding masterpiece, 'Gridlock' is a more thrashy (but in a thoughtful way) track, using repitition and simple structures, in much the same way as 'Time', to create a very interesting tone. 'Intro to Reality' leads beautifully into 'Belly of the Beast' - a true classic - which then cuts to the wonderful bass intro to 'Got the Time' - yet another true classic. 'H8Red' is probably the only below par track. 'One Man Stands' is much like 'In My World' and is just as good, and 'Discharge' tops it all off perfectly.
This was their pinnacle. What came before was definitely great, albeit flawed, and what came after is mainly flawed, albeit with some gems. Now they have reunited with Joey maybe there's room in the world for a follow up to this great record?