The Perfect Storm: A True Story of Man Against the Sea [Paperback]

 

 

Create your own review

Have to admit that I saw the movie first which encouraged me to buy the book, mainly to get more details and check that the movie wasn't just taking artistic license to extreme (as usual). The book was extremely well documented and written, certainly managed to put me off going to sea in storms. As a person who doesn't generally read a lot of non-fiction being able to read this while visualising the movie was great, made the whole experience much more enjoyable.

A gripping account of an exceptional storm at sea, and its devastating effects on boats and aircraft, written by a writer who is a fine journalist but by his own admission has no first-hand knowledge of the sea or of boats. The narrative includes some heroic rescues and attempts at rescue, in a storm which caused substantial loss of life both from vessels and from rescue aircraft.

He has done a conscientious job, and produced a book which is factual and informative and very hard indeed to put down. However there is scope for questioning his interpretation and judgement of the facts regarding one of the major incidents that he reports.

He recounts, factually, the difficulties faced by the yacht "Satori", and faithfully gives in some detail one (but only one) of two conflicting and controversial viewpoints as to their situation. The two crew, at least one of whom was massively experienced, became convinced that the severity of their predicament was such that they were in distress, and they then activated the distress signals. They felt that the skipper had been so overwhelmed by the severity of the storm that he had effectually ceased to function, and in sheer terror and resignation he was just lying comatose in his bunk. That is a damming indictment of the skipper, but it is only one view, and one which the skipper strongly contests.

Eventually, in a massively difficult and risky operation which must be well above the normal operating limit of the aircraft, a helicopter succeeded in evacuating all three persons on board and left the yacht drifting. The owner/skipper refused to leave the yacht, but was overruled by the Coastguard, who resorted to the legal process of declaring it a "manifestly unsafe voyage" in order to have the power to overrule him.

The first thing the owner did after being landed ashore was to get out the charts and plot the position and the likely drift of the yacht, and when the storm subsequently blew itself out and the abandoned boat washed ashore he was there on the beach to meet her and recover her.

That is faithfully recounted. What the writer does not say in the main text, although he does cover part of it in a small and brief footnote in small type, is the other side of the story. Just as at least one of the crew was massively experienced, so was the skipper; it has been reported elsewhere that he was very well known on that coast and had the reputation of being a very sensible and highly competent and experienced skipper. His viewpoint, expressed after the event, was that the yacht was immensely well found and was in no danger of sinking. In that judgement he was in fact proved right by events; it is difficult to fault the argument that, far from being a "manifestly unsafe voyage", it was so "unsafe" that after having been compulsorily abandoned the unmanned yacht continued to look after herself until she eventually washed ashore, and very clearly had the skipper and crew remained aboard this is prima facie evidence that they would indeed have survived the storm - exactly as the skipper expected.

The skipper maintains that far from having mentally and psychologically collapsed, he was allowing the boat to lie a-hull, which is a well established and often successful storm tactic - although he in turn omits to say that in the wake of the 1979 Fastnet Gale that tactic has started to be questioned.

This then comes down to a matter of judgement, and to a legitimate disagreement between the only two (or possibly three) highly experienced people who were actually on the spot at the time.

The book comes down heavily on one side of this disagreement, without adequately presenting the other side, and without making any attempt to evaluate (or to obtain an expert evaluation) of the conflicting views. It has also been reported elsewhere that he made no effort to interview the skipper concerned.

That imbalance is a significant failing of the boom, but with the exception of that limitation it is otherwise a gripping and informative and well-written account of an exceptional storm.

An unsentimental, gripping tale of man against 100 ft waves. After seeing the trailer to the movie, I wasn't sure whether I would enjoy the book ... the movie seemed too "Hollywood". But I couldn't put the book down. Congratulations Sebastian Junger!

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 12 customer reviews...

 

5.0 out of 5 stars A whole other life in 250 pages
Amazing. A life entirely different from yours. Learn about it, feel what it's like at its focal point. In less than 250 pages.

Published 2 months ago by Michal W

5.0 out of 5 stars An expression enters the English language...
It's relatively rare when a book title enters the English language. Yet "A Perfect Storm" is now acceptable usage to describe the confluence of events that greatly aggravate a... Read more

Published 7 months ago by John P. Jones III

5.0 out of 5 stars Outstanding 2
I read the book before I saw the movie, not that it makes much difference. This excellent book meets the standard set by "into thin air", or "life on the line"... Read more

Published 14 months ago by Luke

5.0 out of 5 stars Gripping account of true heroism..
For those who have seen the film, you need to read the book. It represents all that is best about non-fiction. Read more

Published 19 months ago by Peter Buckley

4.0 out of 5 stars I've changed my mind...
...when I reviewed the film, I said I'd never go to sea in anything smaller than a "Nimitz"-class carrier, or alternatively a submarine. Read more

Published on 28 Feb 2007 by Teemacs

3.0 out of 5 stars Not what I was expecting.
This book is very factual, it is really good in parts but only in parts. It has so much fact in it that the story, is somewhat lost in the middle. Read more

Published on 1 July 2001

5.0 out of 5 stars Nail Biting!!
This has to be by far the best book I have ever read!! It is thrilling, sad and above all incredibally well writen! Read more

Published on 31 Jan 2001 by lilster_2000@hotmail.com

5.0 out of 5 stars an amazing read i was uable to put it down
as a fisherman myself i found this an amazing book, the storm sounds horrific and the people onboard the boat must of been in a terrible sittuation, i strongly recommend this... Read more

Published on 15 Sep 2000

5.0 out of 5 stars Wonderful Book!!
I couldn't put this book down, and have already read it twice. I'm not sure I really want to go on any ocean voyages after reading this book!! Read more

Published on 30 Mar 1999

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 12 customer reviews...

Search Listmania!