I have read the book, seen the film, sailed on a tall ship, kept watch, up the rigging, etc. The film is excellent. You must have interaction between people in a commercial film, so criticisms about that are pointless. The scenes at sea, the storm, the waves, the shots of the ships, helicoper rescue, are all so well done, and the final sequence of the central ship meeting the rogue wave mind blowing. The sequence is what actually happens when a ship meets a wave which is too high for it to mount... So see the film and read the book too, and then go on a tall ship...