Prior to reading this, I wasn't familiar with Chet Brown's work. I read one of his comics about 16 years ago, which I probably wasn't mature enough to appreciate. The author was going through a phase of only having 2 small panels per page because he felt normal comic strips seemed 'too cluttered'. As such, I felt he was a little 'too arty' for me. But that is certainly no the case here - Paying For It is a pretension-free & exceptionally honest account of the authors' real-life experience of hiring prostitutes.
His journey begins when his Jerry Springer-esque relationship with his girlfriend leads him to question the socially-accepted ideal of romantic love. I was about to say he became 'jaded' or 'cynical' but I'm not sure the intrinsic value-judgments these words imply are applicable here, since he thinks his decision through in rather a clinical fashion. He decides he doesn't agree with romantic relationships & concludes that the best solution for reconciling his needs with his opinions is to simply pay for sex.
This graphic novel recounts these dalliances, as well as conversations in which he justifies himself to his friends. The 50-page afterword primarily consists of arguments in favour of legalisation of the oldest profession. In this sense, Paying For It is rather one-sided - his friends & the girls are given a voice but aside from
Seth's response to his portrayal in the afterword, their words are ultimately filtered through Chet.
What fascinates me about this work is not only its ability to make the reader challenge their preconceptions but also that so much is ambiguous & down to opinion that everyone will take something different from it. While Chet tries to teach us about the reality behind our assumptions & the perceived sleaze, I felt we ultimately - probably unintentionally - learn more about Chet than we do about anything else.
Yet it's ironically because of Chet's honesty that this strip is not entirely open. For instance, we learn very little about a girl who becomes particularly significant to him because when he tells her he's working on this book, she responds by saying that she doesn't want to be a major part of it. Chet himself admits it's a pity because he is unable to demonstrate just how intimate his relationships with the girls became but it's admirable that he is respectful of their wishes to the extent that he allows it to slightly impede his work.
And what a compelling work it is - shockingly honest & in places, frustratingly enigmatic; thus a lot like a lover itself. It's also of sociological importance since while many books like the infamous
Secret Diary of a Call Girl have been written by the girls themselves, I'm not aware of any others which have been written by the 'johns'.
It's the sort of book you want to lend to friends so you can discuss it with them, as I imagine everyone will take away something very different. After all, I was left with the opposite impression from the one which the author intended - that of a (surprisingly) superficially affectionate but intrinsically hollow, 'quick-fix' industry which, in Seth's words, "just seems sad to me."