|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Utterly Brilliant, 30 April 2005
This is a wonderful piece of concert theatre. Everyone is on good form and seem almost determined to outdo each other.Julie Andrews doesn't sing, but still looks and sounds amazing (though she does need to have words with her costume designer). The true revelation is Linda Eder, who'd been 'bubbling under' before now and finally achieved the complete star status she deserved. Her rendition of Man of La Mancha is amazing - just listen to that note she comes up with near the end, and all whilst looking like it's a stroll in the park for her. Other highlights include Rebecca Luker, Marin Mazzie, Judy Kuhn, Dorothy Loudon's heartbreaking 'Fifty Percent', Debra Monk's hilariously raunchy 'Everybody's Girl' and the party pieces by Faith Prince (Adelaide's Lament) and Elaine Stritch (Ladies Who Lunch (what else!)) Bebe Neuwirth appears in 'Nowadays' from Chicago, but though she's fabulous, she's almost outsung and outdanced by Karen Ziemba. Jennifer Holliday reprises 'And I Am Telling You' from 'Dreamgirls' and just makes you wonder whether she has extra sets of lungs installed. You'll either love it or hate it, but you couldn't fail to be impressed. The only downsides for me were Nell Carter who gets two songs and a quick press of the fast forward switch, and Liza Minnelli who tries to do a rendition of 'Some People' but isn't up to it. It's passable and she does that thing she does now where she knows she doesn't have the amazing voice she used to, but gets by anyway. Somehow though she needs to just calm down a bit. She could have got away with the song if she'd toned down the histrionics. A brilliant DVD though and well worth it for anyone who's into their show tunes! One question - why are these women not ALL household names and huge stars? To a one they have better voices and stage presence than most of the pop divas we're presented with and yet most people haven't heard of them.
|