I should start by saying I own all Joshua Redman's CDs plus a few with him as a sideman (including a couple with Dewey Redman.) So I bought this one from Amazon without hearing it or knowing anything about it. Even if it was not up to his usual high standards, I would have wanted to own it - yes, I'm a fan. I do miss some of the instantly accessible and hummable tunes, like "Faith" from Mood Swing, the opening "Jig-A-Jug" from Spirit Of The Moment, "One Shining Soul" from Freedom In The Groove, "How Come U Don't Call Any More" from Timeless Tales. Passage Of Time is more challenging to listen to, but rewarding. I don't think comparisons with A Love Supreme are valid - if nothing else it is a different time and context which sets Coltrane's master work apart.