1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Great idea, but the plot..., 26 Jun 2002
This review is from: Pasquale's Angel (Paperback)
It's a neat idea. DaVinci puts all his energies into engineering projects, rather than art, and suddenly Renaissance Florence is full of dark satanic mills.
It's very well, and originally, thought out. McAuley eschews special effects and whizz-bang anachronisms (apart from a cheeky little car chase, bravo!) for clever social and political extrapolation, giving us a plausible picture of an unexpectedly industrialised Italian city state. In a pleasing twist, for example, the hi-tech, relatively secularised Italians get first dibs on America, ensuring more cordial relations with the native population, and hence a small dollop of Native American culture taking hold back home (while the rabidly Catholic Spanish froth desparately at the mouth to get some converting done).
All this is done subtly, through convincing, earthy dialogue and unobtrusive, passing details that never feel like the idea is being indulged at the expense of the story. However, it's that very story that undoes all this good work, a locked room murder that develops somewhat incoherently into a full blown MacGuffin chase.
McAuley introduces too many characters, a shame because his two central ones are so well-drawn that we could spend more time with them. He layers up the intrigue so heavily that I had to read certain chapters twice before I could figure out what was going on: not good in something that's supposed to be a ripping thriller.
The major problem, however, is the Big Red Herring. What are all these shady characters after? McAuley spends so much time misleading us on this, that when we finally discover the real object of desire, it feels perfunctory and irritating, like those bad detective shows where the murderer is always, by default, the one least likely to have done the deed. McAuley could, and can, do better.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Exquisite Renaissance Industrial Novel, 9 Sep 2006
IMHO "Pasquale`s Angel" is one of best novels by Paul J. McAuley. First of all it is very beautifully written, secondly - it is very interesting political criminal novel set in industrial Florence of the 15th century, where all technical inventions of Leonardo are used in everyday life.
The worst mistake of all alternative history novels - to use historical environment as rich decoration for modern story with contemporary minded heroes. Usually, by the way, the knowings of history by sci-fi authors who used to write such fiction are very poor. I`m a historian, so I don`t like the majority of such writings.
Paul McAuley deeply knows and understands the spirit of the Renaissance and the Mannerism culture, and because of it he gives to the reader lively 3D vision of this imagined world. So if you like the art and literature of the Renaissance - this novel would be a gift for you, you would meet there many familiar persons. And if "Da Vinci`s Code" - IMHO - with its stupid ideas - could only blur your vision of history and Leonardo`s art, this novel could help to understand Renaissance culture better (there were some dark aspects in this art and in the lifestyle of that epoch).
If you are lover of more hard sci-fi and fantasy - read "Confluence" by Paul McAuley.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Exquisite Renaissance Industrial Novel, 14 May 2006
This review is from: Pasquale's Angel (Paperback)
I`m not agree with the previous reviewers. IMHO "Pasquale`s Angel" is one of best novels by Paul J. McAuley. First of all it is very beautifully written, secondly - it is very interesting political criminal novel set in industrial Florence of the 15th century, where all technical inventions of Leonardo are used in everyday life.
The worst mistake of all alternative history novels - to use historical environment as rich decoration for modern story with contemporary minded heroes. Usually, by the way, the knowings of history by sci-fi authors who used to write such fiction are very poor. I`m a historian, so I don`t like the majority of such writings.
Paul McAuley deeply knows and understands the spirit of the Renaissance and the Mannerism culture, and because of it he gives to the reader lively 3D vision of this imagined world. So if you like the art and literature of the Renaissance - this novel would be a gift for you, you would meet there many familiar persons. And if "Da Vinci`s Code" - IMHO - with its stupid ideas - could only blur your vision of history and Leonardo`s art, this novel could help to understand Renaissance culture better (there were some dark aspects in this art and in the lifestyle of that epoch).
If you are lover of more hard sci-fi and fantasy - read "Confluence".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No