I used to enjoy Jilly Cooper's doorstep-sized romances but felt that she'd lost the way with her last two books: "Apassionata" lacked memorable characters, and "Score" had an interesting idea, but would have been unreadable to anyone who didn't know the back story. This time an extended prologue sets up the history of a new set of characters so that I feel this book could be read as a self-contained novel, although characters from the other books are worked into the story, for the most part very successfully. As one of the few readers who are not a fan of rich and overbearing Rupert Campbell-Black, I was pleasantly surprised that the author managed to give him his customary appearance without allowing him to take over.
This book works well as a sprawling family saga and the father figure, Raymond, is a nice mixture of characteristics, in fact probably the most likeable character in the book. In many ways a perfect gentleman, he has however committed one morally dubious act which is the starting point for the whole story, but I don't think you could fail to sympathise with him. His lifelong rivalry with his employee (and later business rival) David is one of the unifying themes, but just how far has David affected the family?
Because the fate of a valuable painting is the nominal theme of the book, no one romantic storyline takes precedence, but there are several couples who clearly need to find each other, and all of these strands reach satisfying conclusions by means of some clever, if sometimes rather obvious, twists. My favourite pairing involves a splendidly dishevelled and romantic man (but why did he have to have such a ridiculous name?) and a refreshingly "normal" woman. There's hope for us yet!
I suppose the most disappointing thing for me was that DI Gablecross, a pleasant enough character in "Score", was seriously under-used here; if the police were going to be this faceless, why not introduce a new detective we're not already fond of? Otherwise, this is a very fine example of its genre.