Out of Control: The New Biology of Machines, Social Systems, and the Economic World [Paperback]

 

 

Create your own review

Although first published in 1994, this book is a must read for anyone interested in sensible futurist stuff. I have been astounded at how many of Kelly's predictions have come true over the last 8 years (I read this in '96 and have kept an eye out).

The book's style is a combination of personal observations and interviews with leaders in their field. He synthesises a number of different theories and subjects - Hive Mind, Coevolution, Emergence, Network Economics, Distributed Networks, E-Money, Genetic Algorithms, Privacy, Tipping Points and Cryptography and much more to give us a feeling of what the next 20-30 years might bring.

Kelly (executive editor of Wired magazine) has always had a knack of predicting the future with accuracy and there are plenty of predictions in this book yet to manifest.

I can't recommend Out of Control enough. Enjoy.

When a swarm of bees searches for a new home, it behaves like a single superorganism. Expendable scouts explore potential hive sites concurrently, dancing to communicate their suitability, until, abruptly, the entire swarm flocks into its new home. The locus of decision is a "hive mind," a dispersed, shifting collection of instincts and tiny decisions that somehow transcends the actions of any individual, even the hive queen. Ant colonies be have similarly - and so do foreign currency fluctuations, the folding proteins that regulate the internal processes of life, and the predator prey struggles that shape global ecosystems.

The hive mind is a powerful new metaphor. It's not that scientists failed to notice bee hives and ant colonies before. The difference is that novel scientific tools - chaos" theory, for example, and massively parallel computers - have allowed researchers to study and perhaps harness the unpredictable worlds of highly complex, sell-organizing systems such as the hive mind.

In "Out of Control," Kevin Kelly examines the impact of the hive- mind model as it spreads into the scientific and technological communities. Scientists, he says, are beginning to explore more "holistic" problems, in which entire environments are their laboratory, with huge numbers of interacting factors. Steve Packard, fur example, hoped to re-create a prairie ecology in suburban Chicago, an experiment that succeeded over nearly a decade of false starts. He discovered that the order in which he introduced complementary species - grasses and the insects that disperse their seeds - or the timing of a clearing fire in the aftermath of a drought could radically alter the final shape of his reconstituted prairies. Although this and similar experiments, such as Biosphere 2, are competently explored by Kelly, they have already been described elsewhere numerous times). It is in the realm of technology that Kelly, executive editor of Wired magazine, has something to add. In dozens of interviews with academics and corporate researchers, tinkerer- artists in industrial lofts and even beekeepers, Kelly has uncovered a growing subculture that is systematically exploiting the complex forces of the hive mind, evolution and other self-organizing 8ystems. According to Kelly, their robots and smart computer programs will grow and evolve into useful forms, rendering obsolete all "dumb" manufactured goods, such as today's refrigerators, which cannot adapt themselves to ever-changing human demands. Take the smart office." an artificial superorganism" envisioned by researchers in the Xerox lab in California. By embedding computer chips in every office system, from books that remember where you left off to lamps and chairs that anticipate your approach, they hope to create a sensory net that would adjust itself t~ your needs and habits. It could, Kelly reports, function as the opposite of virtual reality: Instead of bringing a viewer into a computer-generated world, the intelligence of the computer would extend into the room itself. But the user would have to surrender some control to a machine mind. If you entered the office of a hearing-impaired person, for example, the higher volume might puncture your eardrum before the room would "adapt" to you.

These practical innovations are interesting and might revolutionize our lives. But beyond these relatively simple applications, Kelly's predictions begin to go badly overboard. These machines, he claims, would blur the distinction between man-made and living beings and give rise to a "neo-biological" civilization; as they take over their own reproduction and maintenance, he speculates, they will slip from our control. The task of the 21st century, he writes, is to relinquish this control "with dignity." This is a frightening scenario, but the reasoning behind it appears lame to me. Despite its lofty goals, artificial intelligence has continually hit dead ends. The snag is that complex calculations take longer -the smarter you make computers, the slower they become. It is simply a copout to say that genetic algorithms or massively parallel computers will somehow allow a fundamental new forms of self-organizing intelligence to "emerge" in some unforeseen and unimaginable way. I do not believe, for example that the realistic computer animation in "Jurassic Park" will eventually lead to the "emergence" of living cartoon characters, like "real" Roget Rabbits as Kelly insists. Nor do I believe, as Kelly posits, that the new wired society will inevitably become more democratic; darker scenarios are equally also possible. Unfortunately, in his highly combustible enthusiasm, Kelly spews countless similar Panglossian predictions that are rather silly.

In the end, "Out of Control" is a mixed bag. At its best, it is a gallery of intellectual and technological pioneers striving to infuse the hive mind into our machines. They just might succeed. But at its worst, it reads like a random tour of the Internet, where solid information is punctuated by the musings of isolated nerds.

REcommended only with extreme caution.

Although first published in 1994, this book is a must read for anyone interested in sensible futurist stuff. I have been astounded at how many of Kelly's predictions have come true over the last 8 years (I read this in '96 and have kept an eye out).

The book's style is a combination of personal observations and interviews with leaders in their field. He synthesises a number of different theories and subjects - Hive Mind, Coevolution, Emergence, Network Economics, Distributed Networks, E-Money, Genetic Algorithms, Privacy, Tipping Points and Cryptography and much more to give us a feeling of what the next 20-30 years might bring.

Kelly (executive editor of Wired magazine) has always had a knack of predicting the future with accuracy and there are plenty of predictions in this book yet to manifest.

I can't recommend Out of Control enough. Enjoy.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 24 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

 

5.0 out of 5 stars good
The book is quite good. It will help me to know some interesting knowledge. At the same time the quality of the book is good and the important is that it is very cheap.

Published 2 months ago by zjh

5.0 out of 5 stars Well Controlled

A great book explaining much of the world around us. Be warned, it's not a quick read having almost 700pages of densely packed text, however it's written in a manner which... Read more

Published on 5 Jan 2010 by Craig Stott

5.0 out of 5 stars Provoke your mind
Simply put, insirational. Programmers, designers, business leaders, inventors, thinkers, writers, architects, scientists - read this.

Published on 22 Mar 2000

5.0 out of 5 stars A must to learn how technology will change our lives
A very convincing book, describing the relationship between technology and life. It certainly helped me to further expand my thoughts on the network economy. In one word: great!

Published on 1 Sep 1999

5.0 out of 5 stars Highly recommended for anyone interested in the future.
Love this book. A great introduction to a world of ideas and concepts about evolution and technologies that are already shaping our (near) future. Read more

Published on 5 Mar 1999

4.0 out of 5 stars A good book but it overstays its welcome
The first few chapters of this book supplied me with the momentum to keep going. Things are not organized well enough to hold a reader's interest once the initial ideas are... Read more

Published on 24 Sep 1998

4.0 out of 5 stars Is There a Swarm in Our Future?
Kelly goes on a wide-ranging journey through evolutionary theory, artificial intelligence, virtual reality, and market economics; he admits that, if "cybernetics" was... Read more

Published on 27 Aug 1998

4.0 out of 5 stars An enjoyable read for anyone interested in Artificial Life
The relaxed style of this book makes it very enjoyable light reading. And yet the author covers a wide range of issues in a captivating way that shows his enthusiasm for and... Read more

Published on 8 May 1998

5.0 out of 5 stars Fabulous book on growing scientific suspicions
The London Spectator's surprisingly enthusiastic recommendation made me buy it. The book is a great layman's guide to a coming revolution in scientific and engineering thought... Read more

Published on 18 Mar 1998

4.0 out of 5 stars Painful but thought provoking evaluation of complex systems
This is the best badly written book I have read lately. Kelly's book provides an enthusiastic reflection on the evolution of complex systems, full of vivid images and provocative... Read more

Published on 2 Feb 1998

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 24 customer reviews on Amazon.co.uk

Search Listmania!