Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Step Forward, 13 Oct 2009
George Mann's previous 'Newbury and Hobbes' novel, The Affinity Bridge was a curious mix of riotous entertainment and horrendous cliché, that teetered on the brink of being truly awful, yet managed to remain a book worth reading. So, it was with some apprehension that I settled down to read 'The Osiris Ritual' - which way would Mann go? Would we be treated to a robust steampunk thriller, or a latter-day penny-dreadful?
I'm pleased to report that some of the problems of the first instalment have been ironed out. Mann's characters and settings now feel like artful homage, as opposed to clumsy pastiche (though some may argue there is little difference!), and although there is still some anachronistic dialogue, the editing for book two is tighter, making for a smoother read and considerably less frustrated tutting.
Again the sleuth's adventures are exciting; this time Newbury finds himself dealing with an Egyptian curse, whilst Hobbes hunts down a mysterious magician, linked with the disappearance of a number of women. The story flows quickly, thanks mainly to Mann's fluent writing style, which is a good job, as it hides 'The Osiris Ritual's' main flaw. The plot doesn't really hold up to close scrutiny. On the face of it, the villain's motives and methods seem sound, but on reflection it's a rather half-baked scheme not befitting for the master criminal he is purported to be. There are some nice set pieces in the book, but I was left with the impression that the plot was fudged to fit around them, rather than things being developed in unison.
Despite that, 'The Osiris Ritual', like its predecessor, is so much fun, that its plot flaws are easy to forgive. If you are looking for an easy enjoyable read, and are not upset by loose plotting, then you could do a lot worse than investigating the exploits of 'Newbury and Hobbes'. They are definite Guilty Pleasure material, perfect for lightening a dreary Autumn evening.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another great story, looking forward to more., 29 Oct 2009
I got into steampunk with Alan Moore and I've been looking for good stories on a similar theme ever since. These stories are great and I am really liking the world that George Mann is creating. I think the Affinity Bridge was a better story and had more possibilities, however, this is just what I want from fiction, good ideas, a new world to immerse myself in and pure escapism. Who wants to read fiction that is real life? I will be collecting the rest and have even started to track down the limited edition hardbacks to get the little curios that come with them. Great covers too. How about releasing these as artwork to collect?
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Second in the Newbury and Hobbs Series, 18 Sep 2009
`The Osiris Ritual' is the second in the Newbury and Hobbs series (if you haven't read it yet, you might be better to go back and read `The Affinity Bridge' first.) The story opens as Lord Winthrop is hosting a party where he will unveil (and unwrap!) a Mummy he discovered whilst in Egypt. Sir Maurice Newbury is at the party and soon becomes involved in a mystery surrounding the Mummy and the untimely death of the men who discovered it. Meanwhile his capable assistant, Veronica Hobbs, is investigating the disappearance of a number of young girls which appears to be linked to a travelling magician.
I had really enjoyed the first book in this series and was really looking forward to reading the next instalment and it didn't disappoint. The steam-punk element of the novels means that the Victorian world we are so familiar with is given a different spin; the portrayal of Queen Victoria isn't as vivid in this book but is still very amusing.
There may be times when Newbury slips a little into being an inferior version of Sherlock Holmes (he even has a Scottish housekeeper and a Moriarty-type nemesis) but this does little to dampen this fast paced and good-humoured sequel!
|
|
|
|