It's always going to be difficult when a new author picks up the torch from the original one, and far more so when the series in question is a cult-classic, famed for its character, wit and scenario, straight from the mind of Bill King. I've been reading and re-reading King's Slayer series since he published the anthology that was Trollslayer almost ten years ago, and have finally plucked up the courage to read the new work in the series, from the pen of Nathan Long. I'm glad I did.
Without giving too much away, much of the story unfolds in a way classic to the series, with our two intrepid heroes heading up a small gang on a presumed suicide mission. For better or worse, though, Orcslayer is a deeper experience than much of King's work, with the story cloaked with a sci-fi (for want of a better phrase) undertone that reaches its psuedo-horror conclusion in a startling manner.
Although the writing style is his own, Long shows a great respect for the seven books past, referencing every major character in them, as well as half the minor ones. His portrayals of Gotrek and Felix, thankfully, remain largely unchanged, Felix keeps his sardonic wit, and Gotrek his gruff exterior - although the latter's character is a more respectful and open being than before.
If, like I did, you loved King's novels, then I utterly recommend Orcslayer. It's akin to King's bleaker entires in the series, but largely retains the aforementioned wit and character. Approach it with an open mind and you may well discover that Long is a worthy successor to a series which was too good to end on Giantslayer.
Seriously, the worst thing about it are occasional quips like "slow-poke", "quarter century", and "you've just graduated from squigslayer to trollslayer", which made me read the rest of the chapter with an American accent in my head.