If your looking for an outstanding treble cd, this one is very much worth getting. Andrew is not some local yokel that some backwater choir director pulled out of a ghetto to exploit, use up, and then throw away. Andrew has had some of the finest training and support available anywhere in the UK, if not the world. He has been performing (almost daily) with other choirboys of extraordinary talent from Carlisle Cathedral, England, since he was six. His dedication and hard work has paid off since he is now the "Head" choirboy at Carlisle. Not an easy task for anyone singing in a Cathedral choir! We arent talking about NSYNC,Backstreet Boys, Brittany Spears type training here. We are talking about a traditional training that dates back a thousand years!! Anyone who has been over to England/Europe, and has heard the choirs in the Cathedrals knows what an amazing talent and skill these boys have. Andrew is a product of this tradition and his voice is flawless. The songs take you on an amazing journey, Andrew is only the tour guide! Despite some "questionable producing/mixing" on some of the tracts, this cd is a real joy to listen to. Im fairly confident thay you will agree as well. I cant imagine what "other cds" G.E. Vesey could have gotten in the mail to make him so negative about andrew's(unless they were recordings from the taxman saying he overpaid and he is getting a huge refund.) One voice is wonderful, and totally worth the investment.