The cover is lovely, the storyline interesting, the Prologue and first chapter good and then... it just goes downhill. Sir Alasdair in 'Devil to Pay' was charming and easy to love, but for some reason in 'One Little Sin' the initial shock of discovering that he has sired a daughter scrapes out all the charms out of his character. His serious disposition, his sudden change in attitude towards attentiveness, his ability to restrain his affections and passion towards Esmee are all very difficult to believe and make him very dull and tepid. His humour and candidness disappear and the plot drags and drags endlessly. The romance that blooms (What romance?) is so difficult to believe and hard to enjoy. Not Ms Carlyle's best in my opinion.