I've been a fan of Will Oldham (aka Bonnie Prince Billy) for sometime now, and loved his pre-music career in a film like Matewan. In recent years, he's started acting again, between the many Bonnie Prince Billy records, and has made appearances in films such as Julien Donkey Boy, Junebug, and The Guatamalan Handshake. Old Joy is one of those typically indie-alt outings that suggest Oldham approaches acting the same way he does his music career - this is resolutely indie and comes with a soundtrack from cult band Yo La Tengo, which is akin to their 'Danelelectro' release in the early zeroes (& not far from the soundtrack to The Straight Story).
Old Joy is one that you'll either love or hate, something pretty much reflected in the reviews thus far - but, c'mon, think about it - an indie feature whose biggest star is a cult singer associated with songs about death and shipwrecks concerning two guys in their 30s going to a hot spring in some hills in Oregon. You couldn't mistake this for The Bourne Identity?
Old Joy doesn't have much in the way of plot or story, which is something shared by many a fine film (Ulysses Gaze, Withnail and I, Fitzcarraldo, Dead Man, 9 Songs, Eloge de L'Amour, Last Days, Zabriskie Point)- so don't let it concern you. Oldham plays Kurt, a hippy type, who arranges to visit a hot spring with an old friend whose wife is currently pregnant. SPOILERS AHEAD...His friend (Daniel) listens to talk radio and has a dog. They drive to the spring, get lost at night, have some drinks and a chat by a fire, go to a diner ("I'll have wet toast" is my new line), find their way, walk to the spring, strip and get into it, chat some more, walk back and return home...that's it!
I found Old Joy mesmeric, like Terrence Malick films, the depiction of nature looks sublime and with the Yo La Tengo soundtrack, it all looks wonderful. I really enjoyed this film, though don't know if it will stand up on repeated viewings - I have a suspicion it will. I found it rewarding and well worth viewing, anyway...