Frankly speaking (maybe someone can enlighten me), the comparison of Byrd as a trumpeter to Clifford Brown baffles me... however, I can definitely see comparing him to any of the greats as a bandleader, because his ensembles were definitely crack tight and full talent (be it via the bebop, hard bop or soul Jazz era.) - - If anything Byrd reminds me a lot of Oliver Nelson... Nelson wrote and arranged great tunes, put together at least one of the greatest Jazz albums of all time and recorded many other greats... but as a sax player, I wouldn't quite say he blew me away at all times. - - The same, in my argument is true of Byrd... clearly a rich enough conceptualist to inspire great ensembles, great session man but when trying to blow high tempo bop (such as Lover Come Back To Me) often flubbed notes painfully, despite streams of great ideas (ideas that he probably hipped his band members too as a professor.) In contrast though, he is at his peak on ballads and tunes that swing but aren't over the top tempo wise (Like Miles Davis, Byrd understood space... sometimes followed in his lead... yet seemed to try hard to stand his own ground - - personally speaking, I'm more into Byrd visa vis all his eras than Davis... Should any of the Jazz Police be reading this, feel free to whine.) - - That said, even when Byrd was flubbing his keister off, ideas flowed in ways none of the "technical perfectionist school" trumpeters ever could, and like a lot of great boxers, even though he may not have landed every punch, when he did, you best better have been grateful that it was a bandstand not a boxing ring, otherwise, you'd have been out for the count.
So we discuss Off To The Races... The presence of Wynton Kelly, Sam Jones and Art Taylor go without saying... The guys go together like bread, peanut butter and jelly... pizza, cheese and tomato sauce... Heck, Manny, Moe and Jack... they were born to swing together... In addition, the ensemble provides grounding for McClean to walk the middle ground... A Charlie Parker worshipper, also capable of playing far out avant garde stuff, here he stretches out, yet swings tastily... and Pepper Adams cooks on the bari.
SUDWEST FUNK represents a great vehicle for Byrd as well as McClean- - a 12 bar blues which allows Byrd to really show off his distinct tone... and for McClean to dig into both a Parker and Byrd vein... in contrast Paul's Pal is definitely Pepper's vehicle... he swings so effortlessly its almost as if his horn has melted down into Dexter's tenor, but still has the room shattering blast of a bari... Byrd answers his solo as only richly conceptual and sharp Byrd can in his league.
The album closes with a jumpy blues that gives Wynton Kelly ample space and let's the ensemble (including the alto/bari/trumpet mix) show off their tightness... Sam Jones also gets a taste... Wynton Kelly also takes a short but ridiculously swinging and punchy solo.
Overall, memorable 1958 hard bop session worth adding to your collection !