I am not reviewing the films themselves, but the quality.
I bought the boxset yesterday, and settled down today to watch the trilogy this morning. I have to say that I completely agree with previous reviewers. The quality of the films on this blu ray set is AWFUL and grainy, especially compared with the DVD boxset I already own. What makes it worse is that I watched The Green Mile on blu ray a couple of days ago, and that was made in 1999 (compared with these in 2001, 2004 and 2007), and the quality was brilliant. I just can't believe what an appalling job they've done with these excellent films. Very disappointed and will be trying to return them.
My advice, don't buy - stick to the original DVDs.