I had previously purchased this lipstick at a department store and "loved" it.
The department store stopped carrying the NVEY ECO products, so I searched to find a source where I could purchased the lipstick from. When I found a place that had it I was happy, only to be disappointed because the company that supplied the lipstick had a poor quality of the lipstick. The color was nothing like the original one I had purchased and the lipstick had white stuff on it, as if it had been left over from an old batch that had dried out. I was afraid to use it becasue I wasn't sure what the white struff was. If the lipstick had come like the one I had orginally purchased, I would be giving it 5 stars, however, based on the product I received, I can only give it 1 star.