Like many reviewers, I found Not Buying It a disappointing read. Disappointing because Judith Levine embarks on an extraordinary adventure in buying nothing but essentials for a year, and yet she shares so little of the experience. I was hoping for ideas and inspiration in my own battle to get out of debt and break free of consumerism. Instead, I got a lot of rather dull musings on economics and American politics, most of which were over my head (and I'm a university graduate).
In places the book reads more like an academic report than a biography, but then Levine's project was academic. She and her partner didn't need to cut down on their spending, not did they choose to do so for ideological reasons. Instead, they set up an experiment with an arbitrary set of rules (tissues weren't considered a necessity, but newspapers were, and they thought nothing of building a large extension on one of their properties during the year). By the end of the book, I didn't have a very favourable impression of Judith Levine. I was irritated by her constant intellectualising over ethical issues; she always seemed to talk herself out of taking any action. This is a woman who appears concerned about the environment, yet regularly commutes between Vermont and New York.
If you're interested in politics, economics or sociology you may enjoy this book. But if your interest is in saving money, my advice is to do just that and leave this book on the shelf.