I'm torn in my feelings about this book. Frederick Busch was one of my favorite novelists, and "North" is beautifully written. With that said, There are many holes in this book, that left me depressed. With the exception of Jack, the main character, the importance of the rest of the cast of characters from it's prequel "Girls", are either downplayed or overexaggerated. If Frederick Busch were alive today, I would ask him why for instance, in "Girls" Jack, at the end of a failing marriage, had just became acquainted with State Trooper Elway Bird. But yet in "North", not only does Bucsh make it seem that they were friends for quite a few years before the timeline of "Girls", but also, out of nowhere, there is this "VooDoo Affair" Jack suddenly had with Elway Birds Wife, Sarah. (I call it a Voo Doo affair because it has no substance, it just miraculously appears out of nowhere in Jack's narrative). Also, Rosalie Piri, whom Jack has an affair with in "Girls" is downplayed in "North" to what amounts to nothing but a fling for Jack, when it was clear in "Girls" Jack had very strong and loving feelings toward her. She is only mentioned by name once in the novel, and another time in brief when Jack tells another character that he once had an affair with a college professor. Also, the beginning of the book "Girls" has Jack and the search team in the snowy field digging out the frozen dead body of Janice Tanner... yet in "North", its repeatedly stated that they never found Janice Tanner... I just don't get what Busch was thinking. Its like Busch wrote "Girls" and 40 years later decided to write "North" (even though it was only 7 years), forgetting the identities of all the characters he had carefully crafted before... with the exception of Jack's conciousness.
That being said, I did still enjoy the book, because as a mystery it is still well written on it own, and will definately keep you turning the pages.